Special Court Police: A Test of Judicial Independence
-
News
-
Just now
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
However, these activities are not automatically deemed criminal if they are carried out without harming others or public interests.
“If conducted without harming others (public interest), it can be permissible,” Fickar noted.
Desi proposes that the reform of the police serves as a critical juncture in this ongoing case.
She argues that the case should not conclude with the designation of suspects.
More importantly, it involves how the internal oversight system operates, how eavesdropping authority is granted, and whether there’s accountability for official orders.
Law No. 2 of 2002 concerning the Indonesian National Police provides a clear foundation for the duties and authorities of the police.
Article 13 outlines three primary tasks of the police: maintaining security and public order, enforcing law, and providing protection, guidance, and service to the community.
“These authorities must be exercised according to law. There is no justification for officials to use the authority granted by the state outside the purposes and limits set by legislation,” Desi elaborated.
If allegations of abuse of authority are proven, accountability should not be limited to field personnel.
Investigators need to unveil the chain of command, the source of orders, the mechanisms for obtaining and using tools, and those who may know or be involved.
Accountability must also be viewed from three dimensions.
First, criminal accountability based on the Penal Code and the ITE Law according to proven elements of acts.
Second, ethical and disciplinary accountability.
Government Regulation No. 2 of 2003 regarding Police Officer Disciplinary Regulations and Police Regulation No. 7 of 2022 related to the Profession Ethical Code and Police Ethics Committee provides a framework for assessing police conduct.
Third, institutional accountability through evaluating oversight systems, protocols for eavesdropping technology use, and control mechanisms over officials’ authorities.
Oversight cannot rely solely on internal mechanisms.
The House of Representatives, through its supervisory role, as well as other relevant supervisory bodies must ensure that law enforcement proceeds objectively and accountably.
“Police reform cannot solely be conducted through changes in personnel or organizational structure. Reform must address power culture, oversight systems, transparency in technology use, and accountability for all official commands,” Desi emphasized.
Additionally, eavesdropping oversight must be established through a system that ensures legality, necessity, proportionality, access restrictions, usage recording, and independent auditing.
It should also be remembered that the right to privacy is not an exclusive right of the President or state officials.
“Journalists, activists, academics, entrepreneurs, civil society organizations, and all citizens have the same constitutional protections. Legal safeguards should apply to everyone without distinction of position or status,” Desi concluded.