Special Court Police: A Test of Judicial Independence
-
News
-
Just now
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
Article 193 addresses treason against the government with the intent to overthrow it.
Investigators must prove whether there is intent as articulated in these articles, as well as how the acts committed relate to the objectives deemed illegal by law.
Desi argued that illegal eavesdropping could be a serious offense without necessarily being classified as treason.
Conversely, if an investigation uncovers evidence of an intention to incapacitate the President’s ability to govern or to overthrow the government, then the elements of treason can be examined based on relevant provisions.
Statements made by state officials regarding indications of treason must be considered as part of the investigative development, not as a legal verdict.
This principle aligns with Article 28D paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution, which guarantees acknowledgment, protection, and fair legal certainty as well as equal treatment before the law.
The presumption of innocence must also be respected.
Being labeled a suspect does not prove that someone is guilty.
“Proving guilt is the authority of the court through lawful judicial processes,” Desi remarked.
She also cautioned against careless use of the term treason.
It should not evolve into a political instrument to shape public perception before the proof process is complete.
“The state must be firm against security threats, but firmness should not compromise legal precision,” Desi asserted.
Separately, Professor of Law at Al-Azhar University Indonesia, Suparji Ahmad, cautioned against hastily framing the case as treason.
Illegal eavesdropping and treason are two distinct criminal constructs.
Each has different purposes and elements, as stipulated in the Penal Code.
Treason requires proof of a specific intent and actions that satisfy legal criteria.
“It is insufficient to base it solely on the status of the person who was eavesdropped, the identity of the alleged eavesdropper, or the evolving public suspicion,” Suparji explained.
Fickar also clarified that law enforcement must distinguish between illegal eavesdropping and espionage.
Eavesdropping is part of coercive efforts in enforcing criminal law that must have court authorization, similar to searches and seizures.
If eavesdropping is conducted without judicial permission, the act can be classified as illegal.
Espionage involves spying activities.