When the Wrong is Justified by the Masses
-
News
-
19 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
READING news about the daughter of Deputy Speaker of the House Sufmi Dasco Ahmad, who has become a target of online bullying, reveals something more disturbing than the bullying itself: the emergence of comments that seem to justify such actions.
Dislike for a political figure, for instance, appears to serve as a rationale for the poor treatment of their family member.
Regardless of who the political figure is, their party affiliation, or their track record, can bullying against their child be justified?
Haven't we all agreed that bullying is fundamentally wrong?
Why does that standard change when the bullying affects someone we dislike?
This is the crux of the issue. We no longer evaluate actions based on their rightness or wrongness but rather based on who is committing them and who is the target.
Albert Bandura (1999), through the concept of moral disengagement, explains how individuals can relinquish their moral judgment, thus allowing them to commit or justify harmful actions against others without feeling guilt.
Individuals who understand that bullying is wrong can come up with various excuses to justify it.
Insults are labeled as criticism. Bullying is seen as a joke. The suffering of the victim is regarded as a deserved consequence.
Moreover, moral responsibility blurs as many people engage in similar behavior.
A person feels their actions are not wrong simply because thousands of others do the same.
This phenomenon is reinforced by motivated reasoning, the tendency of individuals to use their reasoning not to discover truth but to justify what they wish to believe.
When someone dislikes a figure, various pieces of information and events related to them can be utilized to strengthen that dislike.
In psychology, this tendency is known as confirmation bias.
As a result, the same facts can yield different moral judgments depending on who experiences them.
This phenomenon also showcases the operation of double standards.
We condemn bullying when it affects our own children, yet we can justify it when it targets someone else's child whom we dislike.
We demand public officials uphold ethics but sometimes disregard ethics when criticizing them.
We advocate for justice, yet we don't always treat others justly.
This kind of paradox deserves reflection. If standards of right and wrong depend on an individual's identity, morality loses its universal nature.
Social media exacerbates this issue. John Suler (2004), through the concept of online disinhibition effect, describes how individuals can lose some self-control when interacting in digital spaces.
Comments that may not be dared to be expressed directly are easily typed on a smartphone screen.
When these comments receive support, group polarization occurs, where individuals’ views become more extreme due to interactions with like-minded people.
One negative comment invites further negative comments. Group support then gives the impression that such actions are justified.
However, the mere number of people who justify an action does not inherently make that action right.
In organizational science, there is a concept called normalization of deviance, introduced by Diane Vaughan (1996).
This concept explains how repeated deviations can be accepted as normal.
This concept is relevant in understanding societal behavior in digital spaces.
Initially, insults might be deemed inappropriate. However, as they persist and gain support, insults gradually come to be viewed as normal.
Once deemed normal, insults begin to be justified. Even those who remind others that insults are wrong can become the next targets of bullying.
If this persists, it threatens to erode society’s moral sensitivity.
The issue is no longer merely the number of bullies but the growth of a social environment that justifies bullying.
Freedom of expression is an essential part of democracy. Criticism of policies, decisions, and the behavior of public officials is also necessary.
However, criticism of an official should not be passed down to their family. Children should not bear the consequences of society's dislike for their parents.
In facing this phenomenon, mere law enforcement is insufficient.
The Ministry of Communication and Digital has a role in cultivating a healthy digital ecosystem.
Digital platform managers and news media have a responsibility to moderate content that includes bullying.
The Press Council, through the Cyber Media Reporting Guidelines, also provides a foundation for responsibly managing user comments.
The Ministry of Women's Empowerment and Child Protection and the Indonesian Child Protection Commission play crucial roles in protecting victims, especially children.
Law enforcement can take proportional actions when there are elements of legal violation.
However, it is equally important for educational institutions, families, political figures, and society to work towards rebuilding moral sensitivity.
Education should not only produce intellectually astute individuals but also a society capable of distinguishing between criticism and insults, freedom and abuse of power, and courage and rudeness.
Indonesia has a relevant guideline, namely the second principle of Pancasila, Just and Civilized Humanity.
This value of humanity should apply to everyone, including those who hold different political views than ours.
We do not have to like someone to respect their dignity.
We also do not have to defend a figure to say that bullying against their child is wrong.
For wrong actions do not become right simply because many people justify them.