The Vice Presidential Nomination, Green Democracy, and the Need to Change Our Democratic Practices
-
News
-
6 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
VIOLENCE and intimidation against judges represent a serious issue that cannot be overlooked.
Several incidents have shown that carrying out judicial duties does not always occur in a safe environment.
Judges are expected to make decisions freely and impartially, without pressure from any party. The state has an obligation to ensure the safety of judges so that the judicial process can proceed as intended.
This issue has resurfaced following discussions between the Judicial Commission (KY) and the National Police of the Republic of Indonesia (Polri) regarding the proposed establishment of a Special Court Police.
This proposal aims to strengthen the security for judges and the judicial environment while also preventing actions that undermine the honor and dignity of judges (contempt of court).
However, the plan has drawn criticism as it is seen as potentially disturbing the independence of the judiciary if not accompanied by clear limits on authority.
While protecting judges is indeed necessary, the independence of the judiciary should not be sacrificed in the name of security. Both must progress in harmony.
Judicial security should ensure that judges are free from threats and intimidation, rather than placing the judicial process under the shadow of security forces.
Thus, the discussion around the Special Court Police needs to be placed within a broader framework, namely how the state guarantees the safety of judges while maintaining the independence of the judiciary.
The independence of the judiciary cannot be separated from the security guarantees for judges in performing their duties.
This principle must not only be understood as judges being free from interference by the executive or legislative branches but also includes assurances that judges are free from threats, pressure, and intimidation, both inside and outside the courtroom.
Without adequate security guarantees, the independence of judges risks becoming merely a normative principle that is difficult to realize in practice.
Legally, this obligation is affirmed in Article 48 of Law Number 48 of 2009 concerning the Judiciary.
This provision mandates that the state provide security and welfare guarantees for judges and constitutional judges in carrying out their duties.
Furthermore, the Supreme Court has issued PERMA Number 5 of 2020 and PERMA Number 6 of 2020 as guidelines for court protocols and security within the judiciary.