Dismissal 'Without Honor' Not Regulated Becomes Ground for Presidential and Vice Presidential Pension Rights Law Challenge at MK
-
News
-
Just now
Writer
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - The absence of a definition for "dismissal without honor" in Article 6, paragraph (1) of Law Number 7 of 1978 concerning the Financial and Administrative Rights of the President and Vice President has prompted petitioners to challenge this law in the Constitutional Court (MK).
The petitioners argue that this legal void creates uncertainty, as it places the criteria for presidential dismissal entirely within the political discretion of the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR).
"The lack of norms governing the qualifications, parameters, and objective criteria regarding dismissal without honor in Article 6, paragraph (1) a quo, which fully delegates this determination to the political discretion of the People's Consultative Assembly, directly results in a legal vacuum that triggers acute constitutional uncertainty," the petition states, as quoted from MK's website on Tuesday (17/11/2026).
The relevant article reads:
"The President and Vice President who resign honorably from their positions are entitled to receive a pension."
The explanation of the article indicates that any dismissal of the president or vice president is considered honorable, unless explicitly stated otherwise by the MPR.
Therefore, the contested article does not clearly specify the criteria for a president or vice president being dismissed without honor.
The petitioners compare this pension regulation for heads of state with other public profession regulations, such as for Civil Servants (ASN) and Prosecutors, which have clearly defined and measurable standards for disciplinary violations in their rules.
"When a dismissal is returned to the political discretion of the MPR, the constitutional enforcement mechanism risks shifting from constitutional adjudication to political bargaining, which is highly susceptible to subjectivity," the petition continues.
This material testing petition has been officially registered with the Constitutional Court under case number 428/PUU-XXIV/2026, recorded on Monday (16/11/2026).
This lawsuit is filed by three petitioners: I Wayan Satria Pratama Bayu Negara Marcellinoananta Surya Timur, and Agripa Tri Fosa Sianipar.
In their prayer, the petitioners request that the MK amend Article 6, paragraph 1 of Law Number 7 of 1978.
They ask the MK to add definitions for honorable dismissals and dismissals without honor for former presidents and vice presidents, which would be defined as follows:
Honorable dismissal includes
Dismissal without honor includes