• Login
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+

Three Vice Presidents Proposal: Have We Considered the Constitution?

23 November 2026, 05:45 WIB
Nicholas Martua Siagian,
Ferril Dennys

Tim Redaksi

This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original

FORMER Vice President Jusuf Kalla (JK) has emphasized that a vice president must be intelligent.

In this context, intelligence goes beyond academic prowess; it encompasses capacity, competence, experience, and the willingness to actively assist the president in governance.

This is why I continue to write on Kompas.com, elaborating on what it means to be intelligent in the realm of policy, following my previous article titled “Longing for a Technocrat Vice President”.

Academic capacity and intellectual competence become increasingly vital when discussing national leadership needs, especially for the individual who will serve as Vice President, the second-highest office in our republic.

A Vice President must be capable of more than just reading political trends, maintaining coalition harmony, or mediating elite interests.

More importantly, he or she should possess the skills to comprehend national issues from legal, institutional, economic, and public policy perspectives.

It must be understood that the Vice Presidency is not merely a supportive position for the President.

Instead, it is an integral part of the national leadership structure that significantly influences the effectiveness of governance.

Thus, discussions surrounding the need for a Vice President should focus on leadership quality, technocratic capability, and the ability to resolve public issues, rather than simply increasing the number of officials within the power structure.

This proverb is relevant today: “Once the boat has gone off course, it can be turned back, but once words are spoken, the consequences can be dire.”

Once spoken, words cannot always be easily retracted.

Every public idea, especially those concerning constitutional design, should be grounded in legal and constitutional considerations.

This statement also responds to the proposal by the Chairman of the Regional Representative Council (DPD) of the Republic of Indonesia, Sultan Baktiar Najamudin, suggesting that Indonesia should have more than one Vice President, with a maximum of three.

The three Vice Presidents are proposed to represent Indonesia's western, central, and eastern regions, with offices in Sumatra, Kalimantan, and Papua, respectively.

This idea arose when Sultan was asked about the DPD's expectations regarding a successor to Gibran Rakabuming Raka.

According to him, national leadership needs to consider regional expanse and territorial justice.

He cited at least three reasons: the vast and diverse geography of Indonesia, the heavy burden on the President, and the need to strengthen oversight of local governance.

By placing Vice Presidents in various regions, he hopes to optimize the execution of central government programs and the monitoring of local leaders' performance.

It sounds promising.

Indonesia is indeed an archipelago with uneven development challenges. Geographic distance, infrastructure disparities, fiscal capacity, and public service inequalities are real issues that demand central government attention.

However, must all of these issues be addressed by increasing the number of Vice Presidents? I think not!

The Vice President is Not a Regional Representative

From a Constitutional Law perspective, the proposal to have three Vice Presidents contradicts the established executive institutional design outlined in the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.

Article 4 paragraph (2) of the 1945 NRI Constitution explicitly states, “In carrying out his duties, the President is assisted by one Vice President.”

This formulation leaves no room for interpretation regarding the number of Vice President positions in the Indonesian government structure.

The Constitution clearly stipulates one Vice President.

Therefore, the creation of three Vice President positions is not just a matter of government organizational arrangement but involves changing the constitutional design.

This provision is fortified by Article 6A paragraph (1) of the 1945 NRI Constitution, which states that the President and Vice President are elected as a pair directly by the people.

Consequently, the Vice President is an integral part of national executive leadership, not a political representative obtaining a mandate based on territorial divisions.

The Vice President is not designed to exclusively represent Sumatra, Kalimantan, Papua, or any other region.

His or her mandate is national, assisting the President in governing for all the people of Indonesia.

Thus, converting the Vice Presidency into a representation of geographical regions could obscure its constitutional function and position.

Moreover, when a Vice Presidency position becomes vacant, the Constitution provides a clear mechanism for filling that vacancy.

Article 8 paragraph (2) of the 1945 NRI Constitution states that in the event of a Vice President vacancy, within no later than 60 days, the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) shall hold a session to elect a Vice President from two candidates proposed by the President.

This provision reaffirms that the position to be filled is one Vice President, not several positions based on geographical divisions.

If the idea of three Vice Presidents is still to be pursued, the consequence would be an amendment of the 1945 NRI Constitution through the constitutional mechanism as detailed in Article 37.

The question remains, is a constitutional amendment to increase the number of Vice Presidents truly an urgent need for Indonesia at this moment?

We should ensure that constitutional changes are not driven merely by a desire to expand the power structure while fundamental governance issues remain unresolved.

Regional Representation?

It’s necessary to distinguish between equitable regional representation and the establishment of the Vice Presidency.

These are different issues. The Constitution has provided instruments for regional representation through the DPD as outlined in Articles 22C and 22D of the 1945 NRI Constitution.

This body was established to bring regional interests into the constitutional process, particularly through functions relating to legislation, considerations, and oversight regarding regional affairs.

Meanwhile, Articles 18, 18A, and 18B of the 1945 NRI Constitution have established a constitutional framework regarding local governance, relations between central and local governments, regional autonomy, and the recognition of regional uniqueness and diversity.

In fact, the DPD Chairman’s proposal raises a fundamental question: why should oversight of regional matters be strengthened by adding more Vice Presidents?

Then, how do we optimize the function of the 152 members of the DPD RI for the term of 2024–2029, who indeed have a mandate for regional representation in our constitutional system?

This question is not intended to pit the DPD against the Vice President.

Rather, I want to clarify that every state institution should operate according to its constitutional mandate.

If oversight of regional areas is not functioning optimally, the focus should be on evaluating the effectiveness of oversight functions, inter-agency coordination, and existing policy instruments—not automatically creating new positions.

Territorial equity should be reinforced through decentralization, fiscal equalization, strengthening local government capacity, and equitable development distribution.

Issues of inter-regional inequality cannot be resolved solely by placing high-ranking officials in multiple areas.

What is needed more is the local government’s capacity to plan, budget, execute, and evaluate development effectively.

Do Not Increase Bureaucratic Burden

Indeed, suggesting changes is not an issue, but it should be thoughtfully weighed, especially when such arguments are put forth by state officials.

The next concern is institutional and fiscal consequences. The addition of Vice President roles cannot be standalone without supporting apparatus.

Historically, the Vice Presidency has been associated with various financial rights and state facilities as stated in Law No. 7 of 1978 regarding the Financial/Administrative Rights of the President, Vice President, and Former Presidents and Vice Presidents of the Republic of Indonesia.

These facilities include salaries and allowances, household expenses, official residences, state vehicles, health services, security and escort, secretarial support, supporting staff, and travel reimbursement.

All of these are consequences of holding a state office that require budgetary and bureaucratic support.

If the number of Vice Presidents is increased to three, the state must consider the consequences of added facilities, personnel, administrative support, security, and operational budgets.

Moreover, if each Vice President is to be placed in different regions, the institutional and infrastructural needs must also be prepared.

This means the proposal involves not merely adding two positions but potentially enlarging the bureaucratic structure and the state’s fiscal burden.

This issue becomes increasingly relevant as we are facing challenges regarding the effectiveness of government institutions.

In my article on Kompas.com titled: “Two Years of Prabowo: Political Consolidation 'Faster' than Technocratic”, I reflected on the condition of government structure, from a large cabinet composition to additional positions such as special presidential advisors, special assistants, and special staff.

In a situation where institutional consolidation and bureaucratic effectiveness remain a pressing task, increasing the Vice Presidency may risk expanding power structures without guaranteed improvements in public service quality.

The government must first ensure that every existing institution and position operates optimally, has clear distribution of authority, and delivers measurable benefits to the community.

The success of governance should not be measured by the number of positions created but by how effectively state resources are used to address public issues.

In the context of state financial management, each addition of institutional structure must also be evaluated based on necessity, efficiency, accountability, and justifiable benefits.

The Constitution and Knowledgeable Leaders

Ultimately, it is misguided to respond to issues of vast territory, the heavy burden on the President, and weak regional oversight by simply increasing the number of Vice Presidents.

The problem in Indonesia is not the lack of Vice Presidents, but rather the need to ensure that governance operates effectively, responsively, and oriented toward public interests.

Proposals can be made and debated, but the Constitution should not be interpreted solely to justify every political idea.

Let us reconsider the supremacy of the constitution; Article 4 paragraph (2) of the 1945 NRI Constitution clearly states that the President is assisted by one Vice President.

As long as this provision remains unchanged through constitutional mechanisms, there is no constitutional basis for introducing three Vice Presidents.

Democracy does indeed provide space for ideas, but the Constitution sets limits for every proposal.

The issue of national leadership is not about how many Vice Presidents are needed, but rather about the quality of individuals who occupy that role.

Former Vice President Jusuf Kalla was right to emphasize the importance of a Vice President who is intelligent, capable, and able to assist the President effectively.

This notion has long been echoed by Mohammad Hatta in his speech: “The Moral Responsibility of the Intellectuals”, at the first Alumni Day of the University of Indonesia on June 11, 1957: “It is knowledgeable leadership that is sorely lacking in our nation and society today.”

We should maintain Hatta's message throughout the course of this republic.

Our country does not need an increase in Vice Presidents, but rather an improvement in the quality of those who hold the position.

What needs to increase are knowledgeable leaders, not positions of power.



Comment wisely and responsibly. Comments are entirely the responsibility of the commentator as regulated in the ITE Law
Report
Thank You! We have received your report. We will remove comments that conflict with the Community Guidelines and the ITE Law.
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Close Ads

Copyright 2008 - 2026 PT. Kompas Cyber Media (Kompas Gramedia Digital Group). All Rights Reserved.

View