Chairman of DPD RI Proposes Three Vice Presidents for Indonesia
-
News
-
2 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
IN the context of employment, employers collect and manage employees' personal data, ranging from identity and address to bank account numbers and health information.
This data is necessary for administration, payroll, and the execution of employment relations.
In many cases, employees must provide this information to meet job requirements.
This data control places employers under the obligation to ensure that employees' personal information is not misused or accessed by unauthorized parties.
This responsibility now carries criminal consequences. Article 269 of Law No. 27 of 2026 on Employment Protection (UU PK) threatens employers who fail to provide protections as stipulated in Article 46, paragraph (8), letters a to e, with a maximum prison sentence of four years and/or a fine in category IV.
This provision underscores the seriousness of worker protection.
However, there is an issue to consider: not every failure to protect personal data is necessarily a criminal offense.
Article 46, paragraph (8) of the UU PK stipulates eight forms of worker protection. Five of these—protection of personal data, occupational safety and health, prevention of extortion or fraud, prevention of violence and discrimination, and prevention of harassment—are subject to the criminal threats of Article 269. The other three forms are subject to administrative sanctions.
This article focuses on the protection of personal data because this obligation is also governed by Law No. 27 of 2022 on Personal Data Protection (UU PDP).
The UU PDP distinguishes between criminal acts and violations of data management obligations that incur administrative sanctions.
Article 67 regulates acts of unlawfully obtaining, collecting, disclosing, and using personal data with certain elements.
This provision requires intent; some forms of conduct also include elements aimed at gaining profit or potential loss for the data subject.
Article 68 addresses the falsification of personal data with the intent to benefit oneself or others, which may result in harm.
Meanwhile, Article 57 of the UU PDP provides administrative sanctions for violations of several obligations by data controllers and processors, including the obligation of processing security as stated in Article 35.
This distinction is significant. The UU PDP formulates the types of criminal acts and separates them from certain violations of obligations that incur administrative sanctions.
In contrast, Article 269 of the UU PK uses the phrase “not providing protection” without detailing the forms of data protection failures that could serve as a basis for prosecution.
These two laws are not necessarily contradictory.
The UU PK can establish specific obligations within employment relationships, while the UU PDP governs the general protection of personal data. The issue is how to apply these specific obligations without blurring the boundaries of criminal responsibility.
The obligation to protect data and the limits of criminal responsibility are related but not identical. Employers are required to provide adequate security. However, this obligation does not mean that companies must guarantee that data breaches will never occur under any circumstances.
Imagine a company storing copies of employee ID cards and bank account numbers in a digital system.
There are several possibilities. The company might not have implemented appropriate security measures, allowing anyone to access the data.
Alternatively, an employee might misuse their access to take or disseminate the data.
Another possibility is that the company has applied appropriate security measures, but the system was still breached by an external attack.
These three scenarios cannot be treated identically. In the first scenario, it's necessary to examine whether the employer neglected their duty to protect.
In the second scenario, it’s needed to trace the authority, supervision, and actions of the company in controlling employee access.
In the third scenario, it’s important to assess whether the required security measures were executed and how the company responded to the incident.
Data breaches are a serious issue, but the event itself is not sufficient to prove criminal activity by the employer.
Investigations must look at legal obligations, actions or neglect undertaken, employer control over data processing, and whether the elements of the offense and criminal responsibility are fulfilled.
This differentiation is not intended to diminish the company's accountability. Clear criteria are necessary for companies to avoid hiding behind external attack excuses when they have actually neglected security duties.
Conversely, companies that have fulfilled their obligations should not automatically be treated as criminals simply because an incident occurred.
Certainty is also crucial for employees. They need measurable protection, complaint mechanisms, and clear legal consequences when their personal data is misused.
At least three steps need to be taken.
First, the government should establish technical standards for the protection of employee data that align with the UU PDP.
These standards should clarify appropriate security measures, access restrictions, oversight of data usage, involvement of third parties, and incident handling.
Thus, employers will have guidelines to meet their obligations, and employees will have benchmarks to assess the protection of their data.
However, regulatory implementations must not create or expand undefined criminal elements.
Second, law enforcement should have guidelines for the application of Article 269 that adhere to the elements of the offense outlined in the law.
Examinations should consider the forms of violations, unfulfilled obligations, employer control, and the responsibility of involved parties.
In this way, weaknesses in security, misuse of access by employees, and external attacks can be evaluated based on the circumstances and evidence of each case.
Third, lawmakers should evaluate the implementation of Article 269 after law enforcement experiences are available.
If practices reveal uncertainties stemming from the formulation of offenses, the parliament and the president can consider enhancements through legal amendments.
Evaluations should start from real issues, not merely from concerns about overly broad interpretations.
Worker data protection cannot solely be built through severe criminal threats.
The law must also clarify the limits of punishable conduct. Certainty for employers is not at odds with protecting workers; rather, it is part of ensuring equitable law enforcement.