IDR 15 Billion Donation from Raffi Ahmad: A Response to Controversy or a Shortcut to Drown Out Criticism?
-
News
-
4 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - A donation of IDR 15 billion for disaster victims in Aceh by Raffi Ahmad has been promised following public scrutiny over his company's cooperation with several ministries using the state budget (APBN).
The aid is seen as a form of responsibility from Raffi after PT Rans Animasi Indonesia was found to have entered into a collaboration worth IDR 14.69 billion with two ministries from 2024 to 2026.
However, the donation for disaster victims and the debate surrounding the use of public funds are two separate issues.
Humanitarian assistance can alleviate the burden on those affected by disasters, yet questions regarding the procurement process, price fairness, and potential conflicts of interest in government collaborations require clarification.
So, can this donation address public criticism, or does it risk becoming a shortcut to quell controversy without resolving governance issues?
Agustinus Subarsono, a lecturer at the Department of Management and Public Policy at Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM), praised Raffi Ahmad's commitment to allocate IDR 15 billion to assist disaster victims.
He stated that this step reflects social solidarity toward those facing hardships.
However, he noted that this donation does not automatically silence public criticism of Raffi's company's collaborations with several ministries.
"However, I believe not everyone perceives this action as sufficient to end public criticism of Raffi Ahmad's collaborations with ministries utilizing state funds," Agustinus told Kompas.com on Thursday (19/11/2026).
He emphasized that the underlying issue that still needs addressing is the relationship between Raffi's business interests and his responsibilities as a public figure.
Previously, Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) spotlighted the procurement of public relations or influencer services by two ministries via a company affiliated with Raffi Ahmad.
Agustinus argued that these findings should be followed up by relevant authorities to ensure that the procurement prices are justifiable and that processes comply with government procurement regulations.
Thus, providing assistance to disaster victims cannot be viewed as an adequate form of accountability regarding the public funds issue.
"The cases of social assistance and the use of APBN in cooperation are two different matters. Social assistance reflects Raffi Ahmad's commitment and social spirit towards those in need, which I appreciate," he said.
"However, the cooperation with the two ministries in the procurement of services as an influencer needs to be resolved through legal mechanisms so that the public is informed whether there were any legal violations," Agustinus added.
He further remarked that the public needs clarity through proper legal mechanisms and inspections, instead of just explanations or social actions from the figures under scrutiny.
Agustinus also opined that the donation could be seen as an attempt to quell criticism if the fundamental issues concerning transparency and accountability are not addressed.
"The public is not wrong in analyzing that this move is a shortcut to mute public outcry without tackling the core issues surrounding transparency, accountability, and the governance of public procurement, as well as an effort to build Raffi Ahmad’s personal image," he explained.
He noted that law enforcement agencies, such as the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK), police, and prosecutors, still have room to investigate these collaborations.
However, this investigation requires political will and commitment to ensure the governance is free from corruption, collusion, and nepotism.
Political communication expert from UGM and executive director of Indonesian Presidential Studies, Nyarwi Ahmad, remarked that for the past ten years, the government has tended to use influencers as a shortcut to convey programs and policies.
He pointed out that the government's use of influencers is not always accompanied by a selection process that considers their reputation, competence, educational background, or expertise.
"For over the last decade, the government has been fond of taking shortcuts by hiring influencers, and even that is not done selectively," Nyarwi stated when contacted by Kompas.com.
Nyarwi also criticized the government's tendency to use influencers as tools to shape public opinion instead of fostering two-way communication with society.
He argued that government communication should not stop at disseminating messages through popular figures.
The government must ensure that policy information is conveyed accurately, credibly, and responsibly.
"What often happens is not a process of public communication between the government and the people, but rather the use of influencers as hegemonic instruments to dominate public space or mobilize through their influence," Nyarwi said.
He labeled the use of influencers as a shortcut that may lead the government to rely on the popularity of particular figures to reach the public.
However, this strategy carries its own risks.
If the influencers collaborating with the government face public backlash or a decline in reputation, the image of the government agency utilizing their services may suffer as well.
"If this influencer also faces resistance from society, say if they're a celebrity and experience counteractions like cancel culture, then the government is actually the one that loses," he pointed out.
"When the reputation of this influencer declines, it also tarnishes the reputation of the party that hired them," Nyarwi concluded.