BREAKING NEWS! DPR Approves Asset Seizure Bill into Law
-
News
-
8 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - The Indonesian House of Representatives' Commission X is set to establish regulations on the equivalence of education and diplomas issued by foreign educational institutions in the Draft Law (RUU) on the National Education System (Sisdiknas).
This initiative comes in the wake of recent controversies surrounding the educational qualifications of public officials, particularly involving Gibran Rakabuming Raka.
Lalu Hadrian Irfani, Deputy Chairman of Commission X, clearly stated that regulations are necessary to prevent further disputes related to administrative requirements.
"Therefore, we in Commission X advocate for clear and necessary regulations to avoid disputes with other institutions," Lalu Hadrian Irfani said recently.
So, what aspects need to be regulated in the diploma equivalency mechanism to ensure clear standards and procedures?
Education expert Indra Charismiadji stated that the RUU Sisdiknas must outline the basic principles of the equivalency mechanism.
These basic principles include the citizens' right to receive service, transparency, accountability, equal treatment, and an objection mechanism in case of errors.
At the same time, the technical requirements should be flexible enough to adapt to the evolving education systems of various countries.
"We must not let our regulations hinder citizens who genuinely possess valid foreign education qualifications," Indra told KompAS.com on Wednesday (18/11/2026).
He emphasized that the mechanism should be supported by integrity in the issuance of state documents.
According to him, integrity is a more fundamental issue than technical matters.
He stressed that degree equivalency is a process of recognizing the education qualifications obtained by an individual, not a means to create unverified qualifications.
"The state can have various mechanisms for assessing equivalency. However, every decision must have a clear basis and be accountable," he stated.
Similarly, Ubaid Matraji, National Coordinator of the Indonesian Education Monitoring Network (JPPI), highlighted that integrity remains a significant issue within the domestic diploma equivalency mechanism.
Although equivalency regulations exist, they have primarily been internal ministry regulations and not equivalent to legal products such as laws.
"Our problem has not been the absence of equivalency regulations, but rather the weak integrity of verification processes and the susceptibility to discretional loopholes that can be exploited for specific interests," Ubaid said.
Ubaid Matraji, National Coordinator of the Indonesian Education Monitoring Network (JPPI)Verification of foreign educational equivalency must be conducted through honest means without any potential for fraud.
Ubaid noted that this issue distinguishes diploma equivalency in Indonesia from that in other countries.
He explained that the equivalency systems in countries with robust education governance are built on strict competence standards and academic accountability.
These systems are also established transparently and free from political interference.
"For example, in Europe through the Lisbon Recognition Convention, or in Australia and Germany. Hence, the differences in curriculum systems and educational levels among countries are normal, as almost all developed nations have equivalency mechanisms (credential evaluation or recognition of qualifications)," he explained.
Thus, Ubaid warned against allowing the discussion of diploma equivalency in the RUU Sisdiknas to become a "red carpet" or a tool for political legitimization to cover up past maladministration cases.
He does not want any regulatory changes to overlook existing issues.
"Or worse, to facilitate shortcuts for certain elite groups," Ubaid added.
Furthermore, Indra Charismiadji asserted that the government must ensure that the equivalency process is based on educational qualifications, not merely documents indicating someone attended school.
He believes the government needs to differentiate between diplomas or graduation certificates, transcripts, and certificates of attending education.
"These three serve different functions and cannot simply replace each other," Indra clarified.
Additionally, the verification process should be organized transparently and be traceable.
Each equivalency letter must have clear supporting documents.
Similarly, details about who verifies, what is examined, the basis for evaluation, and who is responsible for the decisions must be clearly outlined.
Next, regulations regarding equivalency in the RUU Sisdiknas must define simple procedures and provide certainty in timeframes.
"We must not complicate citizens who have genuinely completed education abroad with convoluted bureaucracy," he elaborated.
Moreover, he argued that the government needs to regulate fairness in equivalency. There should be no preferential treatment for certain parties, including children of officials and affluent individuals.
The same goes for children of migrant workers. Indra stated that everyone should meet the same requirements.
"Public services must not have different standards based on who makes the request," he stressed.
Furthermore, Indra urged the government to distinguish between academic qualification equivalency and professional competence recognition.
For example, in medicine, mere recognition of a diploma is insufficient, as there are competence requirements and licenses to be fulfilled.
He emphasized that the RUU Sisdiknas must be designed to address the long-term needs of national education.
On the other hand, he also reminded that recent diploma controversies should not prompt the DPR to hastily create new provisions without first evaluating the implementation of existing regulations.
"We must not focus on amending rules without questioning why the existing regulations are not being properly enforced," Indra emphasized.
According to Lalu Hadrian Irfani, Deputy Chairman of Commission X of the DPR, this regulation is necessary as the existing controversies have arisen due to the absence of a truly unified reference regulation.
He acknowledged that Indonesia lacks regulations regarding the equivalency of foreign diplomas recognized by the state.
According to him, equivalency of academic results obtained abroad must have its own mechanism. The existing regulations are merely internal regulations from the relevant ministries/institutions, while foreign academic results equivalency should have its own mechanism.
"This is a weakness for us as a large nation; upon reviewing regulations, I found that there are no specific provisions regarding how such equivalency is recognized by the state," he stated, referring to Ari.
Ari views the recent diploma controversies as an important evaluation material for Commission X of the DPR RI and all stakeholders.
Moreover, many Indonesian citizens are pursuing education abroad, thus requiring legal certainty in the recognition process of their education.
He hopes that the new regulations will be binding and eliminate any grounds for debates.
"Let us collaboratively create regulations that truly do not become barriers or sources of debate in the future, as various interpretations arise from our lack of binding regulations on this matter," Ari concluded.