• Login
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+

Tenun Tonic Scam: Why Are People Lured by Online Temptations?

19 November 2026, 09:39 WIB
Fika Nurul Ulya,
Danu Damarjati

Tim Redaksi

This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original

JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - The modus operandi of online scams has now expanded to include offers for side jobs promising additional income.

This scheme is presented through an application that offers simple jobs. Prospective employees are required to pay a deposit under the guise of "training fees" upfront.

Recently, a similar practice was discovered on the Tenun Tonic application. A total of 96 users have reported alleged fraud to the Metro Jaya Police, claiming total losses of up to Rp 1.9 billion after experiencing payment delays.

On the other hand, the tactic of demanding a deposit for participation is not new.

So, why are people so easily lured by promises of extra income online?

Hustle culture and social vulnerability

Sociologist from Gadjah Mada University (UGM), Abe Widyanta, points out at least two reasons why individuals easily fall for enticing offers like those from Tenun Tonic.

First, in the digital age, there exists a cyber culture often referred to as hustle culture, which embodies feelings of guilt or anxiety when one isn't working or chooses to rest.

Exposure to instant success stories on the internet drives them to push themselves to be productively active.

"It’s this kind of psychosocial pressure that dulls their critical thinking. Cognitive exhaustion makes them vulnerable to scams like this," Abe told Kompas.com on Wednesday (16/11/2026).

Second, scammers often exploit social vulnerability algorithms and gamification elements inherent in social media platforms.

Gamification is the application of game-like elements in non-gaming contexts to enhance user engagement.

Moreover, Tenun Tonic's scam operation doesn't resemble a shady investment that is abstract.

According to Abe, its method looks more like a creative activity, a productive economy represented through familiar knitting tasks.

"The process of depositing money is associated with training fees or initial capital (for purchasing production tools), packaged with a reward system based on early achievements," Abe elaborated.

Meanwhile, the initial smooth payments serve to instill confidence, creating a false sense of real social proof.

“Even though, in reality, that is fake,” Abe stated.

Job market factors, literacy, survival

Abe explained that from a sociological perspective, the issue is closely tied to economic pressure, the job market, and digital literacy.

"These three factors do not exist independently. They intertwine in a vicious cycle of structural problems afflicting Indonesian society," he said.

He pointed out that the crisis in formal job opportunities, high unemployment or underemployment rates, and wage stagnation make the working class and middle class vulnerable in their survival strategies.

The digital realm then transforms into a “black market” of hope for people when the formal sector fails to absorb labor.

This situation is exacerbated by low digital literacy in Indonesia. Up until now, digital literacy has often been misinterpreted as merely the technical ability to operate gadgets or applications.

However, literacy encompasses the ability to scrutinize and critique various manipulative practices in digital scams.

"In that acute economic pressure vortex, society finds itself facing urgent needs, which unconsciously diminishes their rational defenses when confronted with instant temptations from scams," said Abe.

The lack of digital literacy ultimately leads many individuals to fail to recognize warning signs of predatory business models, such as being required to pay a deposit as something abnormal.

"Here, the urgency of the victims’ needs makes them easy prey for technologies that are designed to manipulate their psychology," Abe clarified.

What needs to be done?

Abe emphasized that the government plays a significant role in improving economic welfare and literacy among citizens.

According to him, the government should implement systematic reforms that are more radical, rather than just moral exhortations. The approach shouldn't merely involve advising citizens to be more cautious, etc.

Such advisories, he argues, represent a form of shifting responsibility from the state onto the victims.

"The government should undertake more radical systemic reforms, not just moral exhortations," Abe stated.

He suggested several actions the government could take.

First, establishing strict regulations and tough actions against predatory business models.

"Komdigi and OJK should tighten oversight of task-based scam applications (schemes that require upfront deposits). They should intervene before victims are harmed, not just respond after losses reach billions of rupiah," Abe stressed.

Second, revising job creation policies, protecting gig workers, and ensuring social safety nets to prevent citizens from easily falling for false promises online. After all, the root of vulnerability is economic disparity and the narrow scope of formal job opportunities.

Additionally, there must be improvements in digital literacy education in schools and public spaces.

This digital literacy education needs to shift from technical guidance, like creating accounts, shopping online, using various features, and so forth, to critical political-economic digital education.

"The government must more radically educate its citizens on how to read algorithms, recognize the exploitation of platform capitalism, and understand the business logic behind both free and paid applications," Abe clarified.

OJK strengthens coordination

Meanwhile, the Chair of the Board of Commissioners of the Financial Services Authority (OJK), Friderica Widyasari Dewi, stated that efforts to strengthen coordination with various parties would be intensified.

This coordination involves Meta, Google, and the Ministry of Communication and Digital (Komdigi).

Friderica explained that the coordination aims to follow up on content or advertisements that are suspected of being used as means for scams.

Her agency also conducts daily cyber patrols and requests the removal of content suspected of containing fraudulent elements.

"If something appears too beautiful, too extravagant, too good, we should avoid it with logic. Because in everyday life, many malicious individuals are lurking around us," she said.

She acknowledged that cross-border crimes, including part-time job scams, also pose a challenge due to their organized nature.

Therefore, handling these issues requires cross-institutional coordination, including with the Indonesian National Police (Polri).

"We must observe this together," she asserted.

A glance at Tenun Tonic

So far, the Metro Jaya Police are still further investigating the application. The official report received by the police on November 16, 2026, from 96 victims states that the losses reached Rp 1.9 billion.

Through its official Instagram account, Tenun Tonic promotes the knitting of neck scarves, which they claim can be completed in about 30 minutes for extra income.

Before starting, users are asked to pay a deposit, labeled as a training fee.

Once the scarves are completed, users are instructed to send their knitted items to the Tenun Tonic office located at Ruko Palm Avenue Block H, Kalideres, West Jakarta.

The knitted items are then promised to earn commission. However, many users later complained about not receiving promised payments.



Comment wisely and responsibly. Comments are entirely the responsibility of the commentator as regulated in the ITE Law
Report
Thank You! We have received your report. We will remove comments that conflict with the Community Guidelines and the ITE Law.
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Close Ads

Copyright 2008 - 2026 PT. Kompas Cyber Media (Kompas Gramedia Digital Group). All Rights Reserved.

View