Preventing Recurrence of Illegal Eavesdropping, How Strong is the Oversight in the Bill?
-
News
-
5 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
EVERY time a high state position becomes vacant, politics swiftly moves to find a replacement.
Public discourse is filled with speculations: who will be chosen, which parties will benefit, who must yield, and how the coalition balance will be rearranged.
All of this is part of political dynamics. However, something feels missing when attention is too long consumed by the struggle for positions: the conversation about the purpose of power itself.
The decision by Gibran Rakabuming Raka to vacate the Vice Presidency on November 12, 2026, tests our political maturity once again.
Public attention is immediately drawn to the puzzle of succession and compromises among political powers.
Yet, this intersection should encourage us to ask a much more essential question: What kind of Vice President do the people genuinely await?
What values, capacities, and responsibilities should uphold this esteemed position?
Constitutionally, the mechanism for filling the Vice Presidential vacancy has indeed been clearly outlined in Article 8 paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution.
However, behind this neatly procedural framework lies a far more fundamental and pressing question: will this reshuffling of composition give birth to a new direction for the nation's journey, or will it merely be a ceremony of face changes on a stage whose roles remain the same?
Mature democracy should not stop at the issue of who holds the reins.
Its deepest essence lies in the purpose for which power is dedicated, whose voices and interests are genuinely fought for, and what tangible changes are felt by the grassroots.
Indonesia is not lacking in individuals who aspire to hold positions.
However, a significant task remains to present leaders who can ensure that power leaves a lasting impact, even after their term ends.
A concerning symptom in our politics is the tendency to measure success by proximity to the center of power, the number of positions obtained, or the ability to maintain coalitions.
Such measures keep politics busy managing job distributions, but provide little space for debates about developmental directions.
We know who is negotiating, but we do not always know what ideas are being fought for.
In the process of filling the Vice Presidential position, the public certainly has the right to demand transparency regarding the proposed figures along with the political calculations behind them.
And public debates should not stop at who is close to whom or which party reaps the benefits.
Capacity, integrity, track record, and the depth of national ideas must stand firm as the main benchmarks.
Indonesia needs a far more substantive political conversation that touches on the root issues.
How will national leadership respond to challenges in education, job creation, social inequality, technological independence, and the increasingly urgent ecological crisis?
To what extent can leaders strengthen state institutions while nurturing the breath of democracy?
Public office is not a reward for those who manage to build elite support, but a mandate to advocate for the interests of the people.
When politics is more busy accommodating interests and distributing influence, the aims of power lose their direction.
Democracy ultimately becomes just a mechanism for distributing positions, not a means to enact change.
This situation indicates a crisis of political imagination—a failure to build a national vision that transcends electoral interests and short-term compromises.
In The Human Condition (1958), Hannah Arendt introduces the concept of natality, the human ability to initiate something new.
This idea positions politics as a space for change and opening possibilities for the future.
However, change cannot rely solely on the vision and will of one leader.
In Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance (1990), Douglass C. North elucidates the importance of institutions and rules in determining societal development trajectories.
This thought emphasizes that sustainable development requires strong institutions, consistent policies, and rules that can limit the dominance of personal or group interests.
In Indonesia's context, it serves as a reminder that the nation's future should not continuously rely on the currently ruling figure.
Integrity in leadership must walk hand in hand with strong institutions so that development agendas do not shift every time power changes hands.
Therefore, political success should not be measured merely by who gains a position or how much influence is retained.
The real measure lies in power's ability to bolster institutions, produce sustainable policies, reduce inequalities, and enhance public welfare.
Ultimately, what needs to be upheld is not the interests of officeholders, but the future of the republic and the people's interests.
Max Weber, in his essay Politics as a Vocation (1919), distinguishes between the ethics of conviction and the ethics of responsibility.
Politics cannot be driven solely by lofty intentions. A leader must consider the consequences that might arise from decisions they make.
This principle is relevant in the selection of the Vice President.
Political considerations may arise since democracy indeed involves negotiation. However, negotiations must be subjected to public interest responsibilities.
Therefore, potential candidates should be evaluated through measurable criteria: integrity, leadership capacity, understanding of national issues, track record of public service, ability to operate within constitutional limits, and competence to effectively carry out the Vice President's functions.
The public also has the right to know the reasons behind the President's choices and the consideration processes taking place in the MPR.
Transparency does not mean that all political discussions must be displayed, but the final decisions should be reasonably explained.
Political parties should also accept more substantive success criteria.
The quality of a party is not determined by the number of cadres in positions but by its ability to prepare leaders, establish agendas, supervise the government, and absorb public aspirations.
A healthy coalition is based on program agreements and accountability mechanisms. If a coalition merely serves as a means to allocate influence, it can easily degenerate into transactions that do not guarantee policy continuity.
Democracy also requires a functional opposition and criticism.
Criticism is not a disruption to stability, but a way to test whether the government is using its authority appropriately.
Civil society, universities, professional organizations, media, and citizen groups must have the space to express their assessments.
Without open oversight, elite decisions may easily lose corrections, and the gap between government agendas and citizens' needs widens.
National issues are not resolved in just one term. Quality education requires long-term investment. Strengthening research and technology calls for a consistent ecosystem.
Industrialization necessitates certainty of direction, skilled labor, and innovation support.
Social protection requires accurate data and trustworthy governance.
Meanwhile, environmental degradation and climate change demand decisions that are not always popular but are crucial for the safety of future generations.
In A Theory of Justice (1971), John Rawls develops the principle of just savings to explain intergenerational responsibilities.
Each generation is obliged to maintain institutional conditions and resources so that the next generation continues to have the opportunity to live in a just society.
This idea places public policy within a longer time horizon. Governments are not only responsible to the citizens who elect them today but also to those who will bear the consequences of today's decisions in the future.
Therefore, economic growth is not enough to be the sole measure of success.
We need to ask whether growth creates decent jobs, whether investments strengthen national production capabilities, whether development reduces inter-regional disparities, and whether resource management preserves environmental support.
Numbers may indicate progress, but the life experiences of the community test whether that progress is truly just.
From this perspective, the quality of the Vice Presidential transition can be assessed through three criteria.
First, constitutional continuity: the process follows the rules and respects the division of powers.
Second, policy continuity: strategic agendas have clear targets, budgets, implementers, and evaluations, so they do not change merely due to changes in figures.
Third, accountability continuity: the government remains open to criticism, explains its decision bases, and is willing to correct harmful policies. All three link political procedures with the outcomes felt by society.
Ultimately, what needs to be addressed is not just how to fill positions but the orientation in using power.
Positions are tools for service, not objectives to be fought over.
Coalitions are means of governance, not measures of political success.
Therefore, the legitimacy of power should reflect its ability to deliver justice, expand welfare, and guarantee a future for the generations to come.
Positions have a time limit, and power will transfer.
However, responsibility for the nation’s future must not cease with the end of one’s term.
Indonesia needs a government that is not only busy maintaining political balance but also building a better foundation for life for future generations.
After all, the most important legacy of a government is not the composition of power or success in maintaining coalitions, but rather stronger institutions, empowered societies, and a more just future.
Therein lies the true meaning of politics: not on who holds power, but on what changes can be realized through that power.