Raffi Ahmad, Influencer, and the Temptation of Power
-
News
-
Just now
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
NOT YET built, the People's School near the University of Indonesia (UI) has already sparked debate. It is not opposition to education for poor families that is at issue, but rather the inconsistent explanations regarding the construction location.
A program intended to bring hope is instead initiated amidst conflicting information between institutions.
Minister of Social Affairs Saifullah Yusuf initially mentioned approximately eight hectares of land designated as part of UI's City Forest.
The university later clarified that the land is located in Jakarta, near the city forest, but not within it.
Jakarta Governor Pramono Anung raised objections to any potential conversion of the forest area.
The Minister of Social Affairs later clarified that the school’s location is adjacent to the city forest, not encroaching upon it.
The public is understandably questioning: where will the school actually be built? Why haven’t the explanations regarding the location been aligned when the plans have already been made public?
Such uproar can easily be misconstrued as a mere public relations issue. In reality, the differing explanations relate to the stages of policy: who proposed the location, who verifies asset status, who assesses environmental impact, and when the decision is finalized.
When these stages are not clearly understood, even accurate clarifications can come too late.
This question transcends land issues; it concerns how power communicates policies, manages differences, and nurtures public trust.
The People's School is part of the poverty alleviation agenda of President Prabowo Subianto's administration.
Presidential Regulation Number 120 of 2025 serves as the foundation for implementing basic and secondary formal education based on dormitories funded by the government. The aim is to expand educational opportunities for children from less privileged families.
This idea is rooted in a strong social justice foundation. Education opens social mobility and helps break the cycle of intergenerational poverty.
However, good intentions do not automatically justify every choice in implementation. The legitimacy of the goal must be distinguished from the legitimacy of the process.
Building a school near the university could foster academic collaboration, student mentoring, and access to knowledge.
However, the choice of location requires certainty regarding land status, spatial planning compliance, and ecological considerations.
A campus is not merely a collection of buildings. It is also a knowledge space and environment whose benefits extend beyond the current generation.
Schools need certainty so that construction is not delayed. Conversely, limited green spaces require protection to ensure their benefits are not lost due to short-term decisions.
Both interests relate to public welfare, although the measurements of success differ. This is where policymaking requires more detailed explanations than slogans about favoritism.
Therefore, the debate should not be simplified into a choice between a school and the forest. The question is whether alternative locations have been openly assessed and whether decisions can be held accountable.