• Login
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+

Political Opportunism Amidst Power Turmoil

17 November 2026, 05:05 WIB
Rommy Fibri Hardiyanto,
Ferril Dennys

Tim Redaksi

This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original

DECISION by Gibran Rakabuming Raka to resign from his position as vice president marks a new chapter in the political turmoil of Indonesia.

This decision arose as elite relationships came under scrutiny, following allegations of illegal wiretapping involving President Prabowo Subianto and several national figures.

During a meeting with Commission III of the House of Representatives, National Police Chief Suyudi Ario Seto revealed allegations concerning the role of former Police Chief Listyo Sigit Prabowo as the directive authority and ultimate recipient of the wiretapping results.

This situation adds to the political tension previously colored by debates regarding Gibran's position as vice president, including the proposal for invoking the right to express opinions in the House.

Meanwhile, the wiretapping case raises questions regarding the use of state authority, loyalty, and the potential for competing interests within the circle of power.

There is currently no evidence directly linking the two events, let alone confirming the involvement of parties outside those mentioned in the investigation.

Beneath the uproar lies a more fundamental issue. Political relationships built on coalitions, electoral support, and power agreements can shift when the interests of the involved parties no longer align.

Friends turn into foes, allies transform into competitors, while the principles once advocated risk being sidelined by power calculations.

The question is whether this shift represents a natural democratic dynamic or a sign of deepening political opportunism.

Political Noise That Never Ends

Indonesia's politics seem to move from one controversy to another.

Before old issues receive adequate explanations, public attention is captured by new events. The uproar changes, but questions about accountability often get left behind.

The polemic surrounding the Constitutional Court's ruling on the age limit for presidential and vice-presidential candidates ahead of the 2024 elections serves as an example.

The Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court imposed ethical sanctions on the then-chairman.

However, questions regarding the independence of the institution and the relationship between power and political processes do not simply end.

Changes in KPU regulations and the polemic surrounding Gibran's educational qualifications further add to the debate.

Now, allegations of wiretapping bring to the forefront issues regarding the use of state authority.

Clarifications about Listyo's role must undergo independent verification. Speculation linking him to Joko Widodo or other parties cannot be considered fact without proof.

These events differ legally. However, they all highlight the importance of institutions working consistently, irrespective of shifting political relationships.

The public requires processes that can be scrutinized, rather than noise that passes without accountability.

Democracy requires compromise. Parties build coalitions, governments seek parliamentary support, and differing interests converge to facilitate policy-making.

Changing alliances do not automatically imply ethical violations.

However, compromise differs from opportunism. Compromise seeks common ground without sacrificing core principles, while opportunism treats principles as interchangeable for fleeting benefits.

Friends become foes, foes suddenly turn into allies, while the public receives inadequate explanations regarding the reasons for these changes.

The problem is not merely personal loyalty among leaders.

In a democracy, loyalty to the constitution and public interests should take precedence over loyalty to individuals or groups.

Opportunism is often cloaked in seemingly reasonable justifications: stability, unity, or sustainable development. These justifications may be valid.

However, society has the right to question whether the shift in stance is truly in the interest of the state or merely facilitates the distribution of political gains.

Here, political communication becomes crucial. Changes in elite stance cannot simply be justified with the claim that circumstances have changed.

The public needs to know what interests are being pursued, which principles are being upheld, and what consequences must be borne. Without transparency, political communication easily turns into justification for decisions already made.

Opportunism and the Shrinking Opposition

Does the lack of opposition encourage opportunism, or does opportunism lead to a diminishing opposition?

Both may reinforce each other. When positions and resources become the main attractions, being outside the government feels less advantageous.

Conversely, when oversight weakens, changes in allegiance for the sake of power encounter increasingly fewer corrections.

Sociologist Niklas Luhmann identifies the distinction between government and opposition as essential to democracy.

The opposition is not merely a group lacking cabinet seats. Its existence enables the government’s decisions to be questioned, alternatives to be offered, and the transition of power to remain a legitimate option.

Problems arise when nearly all political forces cluster around the government.

Differences of opinion risk being settled through the distribution of power access rather than policy debates. Democracy still has elections and parliaments, but choices available to the public become increasingly indistinguishable.

In the Indonesian context, the position of the PDI Perjuangan, which did not join Prabowo's cabinet, deserves appreciation.

Megawati Soekarnoputri stated that her party supports policies that benefit the people while remaining critical of policies deemed deviant.

However, being outside the cabinet does not automatically signify effective opposition. The measure is consistency in oversight and the ability to offer policy alternatives.

Parties supporting the government also have a duty to oversee the executive. Coalition loyalty should not erase parliamentary independence.

Reflections from the Philippines and Malaysia

The Philippines illustrates how rapidly electoral alliances can change.

Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and Sara Duterte won the 2022 elections through the UniTeam, but the ties between the two political families deteriorated thereafter.

Filipino political scientist Aries Arugay describes how the rivalry between dynasties and elite interests loom over that alliance's fracture.

Malaysia offers a different lesson. The Sheraton Move in February 2020 ended the Pakatan Harapan government after support in parliament shifted.

The change in allegiance of several elites facilitated the formation of a new government without an election.

Neither case is a mirror of Indonesia. The Philippines reveals the vulnerability of political family alliances, while Malaysia demonstrates the impact of shifting support in parliament.

The lesson is not that alliances should never change, but rather that such changes must be accountable to voters.

Public mandates should not be trampled by closed agreements among elites.

Current political upheavals test the ability of state institutions to maintain boundaries between political interests and constitutional authority.

Investigations into wiretapping allegations should remain independent, without shielding or sacrificing anyone due to political ties.

Filling the vice presidential vacancy must also adhere to the constitution, prioritizing capacity, integrity, and the nation's interests, not merely coalition balance.

The House of Representatives must oversee the government without using its authority as a bargaining tool.

Parties need to strengthen internal democracy, while judicial institutions and election regulators must consistently uphold independence.

Legal sociologist Chris Thornhill’s thoughts remind us that the constitution is closely linked to how power gains legitimacy while being constrained.

Thus, the constitution should serve as a guide when elite interests shift, not as a tool continually adjusted to the whims of those in power.

Ethics must not remain a mere moral call. It requires robust institutions, transparent decisions, and the willingness of elites to accept the consequences of violations.

Civil society, academia, and the press must also safeguard independent critical spaces.

The challenge for Prabowo is not only to maintain political support amid changing relationships among elites but also to ensure his administration continues to function when public trust is tested.

In sensitive social, economic, and political situations, the firmness in upholding rules can become a foundation for greater stability than shifting elite agreements.

A state is not a company where shareholders can freely alter agreements for their own profit.

Power derives from public mandates and must be accountable to the people.

Coalitions may change, leaders may shift, but principles should not be up for trade.

The greatest threat to democracy is not merely the battles among elites but when society loses faith that anyone in power is still willing to abide by the same rules and principles.



Comment wisely and responsibly. Comments are entirely the responsibility of the commentator as regulated in the ITE Law
Report
Thank You! We have received your report. We will remove comments that conflict with the Community Guidelines and the ITE Law.
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Close Ads

Copyright 2008 - 2026 PT. Kompas Cyber Media (Kompas Gramedia Digital Group). All Rights Reserved.

View