• Login
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+

"Hompimpa" in Bureaucracy

13 October 2026, 02:10 WIB
Gita Sulika Sari,
Tim Kompas.com

Tim Redaksi

This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original

“Hompimpa alaium gambreng.”

FOR many, that phrase evokes memories of childhood homes.

From the hand game where palms are randomly opened or closed, it determines who stands guard and who can hide.

There is no grudge, no lawsuits. Winning and losing are simply part of the game, ending as evening falls.

But what if the random logic of hompimpa, where winners are decided solely by luck, quietly infiltrates the corridors of state bureaucracy?

Bureaucracy is clearly not a playing field. Public office chairs carry legal authority, budget management duties, and strategic decisions whose effects flow directly to the lifeblood of society.

The quality of healthcare services, educational standards, and ease of business licenses are determined by who occupies that chair.

Therefore, appointing officials based on the logic of "who gets the turn" or subjective closeness is a governance failure.

Spoils System and Crisis of Expectation

In public administration, sociologist Max Weber warned through the concept of Rational-Legal Bureaucracy that ideally, modern bureaucracy should be driven by principles of impersonality, technical qualifications, and measurable rules.

Weber positioned the merit system as an antidote to the spoils system—a practice of distributing public positions as political "gifts", favoritism, or patronage ties.

Unfortunately, in our bureaucratic reality, the shadow of the spoils system has not entirely dissipated.

In many institutions, we often witness scenarios that raise significant questions.

Dedicated employees with years of clean records and stellar performance often find their careers stalled.

Conversely, individuals with unclear track records suddenly soar to strategic positions.

Indeed, career acceleration does not always equate to nepotism. Specific organizational needs may often demand particular qualifications.

The fundamental issue arises when such decisions are "opaque" and unable to be rationally explained to the internal public.

Organizational psychologist Victor Vroom, in his Expectancy Theory, explains that employee motivation is largely determined by instruments of justice: the belief that hard work (effort) will yield performance (performance), and that outstanding performance will be fairly rewarded through promotions (instrumentality).

When this relationship is severed due to random and subjective promotional decisions, bureaucrats' internal motivation collapses.

As office spaces fill with whispers like, “Why him/her?” or “What's the point of working hard if the outcome is dictated by others?”, the bureaucracy faces an acute trust deficit.

Top civil servants may choose to adopt a passive stance (quiet quitting), and even grand office buildings lose their spirit of service.

Between Data and "Feelings"

Normatively, Indonesia has actually prepared a foundation for progressive reform.

Following the dissolution of the Civil Service Commission (KASN) through Law No. 20 of 2023 regarding ASN, the monitoring functions and implementation of the merit system have been strictly consolidated by the Ministry of PANRB and BKN.

This seriousness is emphasized by the issuance of Ministry of PANRB Regulation No. 19 of 2025 on the Implementation of the Merit System and PermenPANRB No. 20 of 2025 on ASN Talent Management.

These regulatory frameworks are no joke: they govern promotion criteria based on qualifications and competencies, the formation of a talent pool, the use of a nine-box matrix, and the precise development of succession planning.

This instrumental approach is backed by the National Civil Service Agency (BKN), which actively promotes the ASN Profiling (ProASN) program.

The national target is massive: mapping the potential, managerial competencies, socio-cultural profiles, and even digital literacy of 600,000 ASNs comprehensively by December 2026.

Technically, the national talent map is being formed digitally and integrated.

However, this is where the true test lies: Will this data map genuinely serve as a compass during promotional decision-making?

It would be ironic for significant national resources and budgets to be spent conducting massive assessments and building intelligent information systems.

Yet, when a vacancy arises, the Personnel Supervising Officer (PPK) often reverts to "intuition": subjective preferences of leaders, local political compromises, or familial relations.

Reports and oversight records from the Indonesian Ombudsman often note that the vulnerable points for maladministration frequently occur at the discretion of leaders who ignore the results of official assessments.

The Message Delivered

Every promotional decision essentially sends a cultural signal throughout the organization.

When promotions are consistently awarded based on objective competency data and track records, ASNs receive a clear message: achieving excellence and maintaining integrity is the only path to career advancement.

Conversely, if non-merit factors dominate, the message conveyed is cynicism: “What’s the point of innovating and participating in profiling tests if the end result is determined by backroom lobbying?”

This cynicism gradually cripples the ambitions of the best bureaucrats, pushing them to work merely to fulfill administrative obligations.

Ultimately, the public does not care how complex the nine-box matrix algorithm functions or how sophisticated the HR dashboards are showcased.

What the people at the front lines need is the fruit of the leadership produced: whether healthcare services are faster, business permits are more transparent, and social assistance is more accurately targeted.

The merit system is not a slogan about who deserves to be promoted, but a moral obligation to provide public leadership that serves (servant leadership).

Public office chairs are a mandate for managing the state, not entertainment prizes or lottery draws.

The biggest homework facing our bureaucracy reform today is not to add more regulations or launch new applications, but the courage and integrity of leaders to comply with the data they themselves generated.

We should be proud to have left the game of hompimpa in our childhood. However, it is tragic if, behind the desk of power, we still allow the fate of public service to be determined by methods akin to hompimpa.



Comment wisely and responsibly. Comments are entirely the responsibility of the commentator as regulated in the ITE Law
Report
Thank You! We have received your report. We will remove comments that conflict with the Community Guidelines and the ITE Law.
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Close Ads

Copyright 2008 - 2026 PT. Kompas Cyber Media (Kompas Gramedia Digital Group). All Rights Reserved.

View