Prabowo Gathers Gerindra Cadres in Hambalang, Dasco and KDM Attend
-
News
-
2 hours ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - The government responded to the lawsuit against the IKN Law at the Constitutional Court (MK) by affirming that the planning of the new Capital City in East Kalimantan has involved public participation.
"The master plan for the Capital City also actively and continuously involves community participation while taking into account the communities affected by the development," said Kurniawan Ariadi representing the government side during the continued session at the Constitutional Court, as quoted from the MK press release on Thursday (24/9/2026).
Kurniawan Ariadi is an Expert Staff for Institutional Relations at the Ministry of National Development Planning/National Development Planning Agency (Ministry of PPN/Bappenas).
He explained that Article 37 of Law Number 3 of 2022 concerning the Capital City (IKN Law) regulates that communities can participate in the preparation for the construction, relocation, and management of IKN through public consultations, deliberations, partnerships, aspiration submissions, and other forms of community involvement.
The trial focused on testing the phrase "taking into account" in Article 21 of the IKN Law. Here is the text of the article in question.
Article 21 of the IKN Law:
Spatial planning, land affairs and transfer of land rights, the environment, disaster management, as well as defense and security as referred to in Articles 15 to 20 shall be carried out by taking into account and providing protection for the rights of individuals or communal rights of indigenous peoples and cultural values that reflect local wisdom.
In their argument, the petitioners claim Article 21 of the IKN Law contradicts Article 1 paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution.
This is because the phrase "taking into account" reduces indigenous peoples to passive objects, offering no opportunity for them to determine the fate of their customary territories.
Regarding this argument, Kurniawan said the people's sovereignty as stated in Article 1 paragraph (2) is exercised through constitutional mechanisms via state institutions and through established democratic processes.
"People's sovereignty cannot be interpreted as requiring that every state development policy must first obtain individual or collective approval from every affected community group," Kurniawan stated.
Regarding the petitioners' argument about the implementation of the principle of free, prior, and informed consent (FPIC), also known as PADIATAPA, the government acknowledges and respects the unity of customary law communities along with their traditional rights as long as they remain alive and in accordance with societal development and the principles of the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia.
"The embodiment of this principle in IKN development is stipulated in Article 21 of the Capital City Law through the obligation to take into consideration and provide protection for the rights of indigenous peoples and cultural values that reflect local wisdom," Kurniawan added.
However, the government views the existence of the FPIC principle as not implying that every state policy or action potentially impacting Indigenous Law Communities must always require collective approval as an absolute veto right.
"Within the national legal system, FPIC principles are accommodated through the state's obligation to provide adequate information, involve communities in decision-making processes, allow space for aspirations, and protect the rights and interests of affected communities according to the characteristics of the activities," Kurniawan explained.
The government's view is that the phrase "taking into account" in Article 21 of the IKN Law already includes an obligation to identify, consider, and factor in the interests, rights, and potential impacts on communities.
"Meanwhile, the phrase 'providing protection' mandates measures to prevent, minimize, and address detrimental impacts in accordance with legal provisions," Kurniawan said.
Previously, the Balik Sepaku Indigenous Community and the Indigenous Peoples Alliance of the Archipelago (AMAN) challenged Article 21 of Law Number 21 of 2023, concerning Amendments to Law Number 3 of 2022 on the Capital City (IKN Law).
Both parties contest the phrase "taking into account" in Article 21 of the IKN Law, which reads, "Spatial planning, land affairs and land rights transfer, environmental management, disaster mitigation, as well as defense and security as referred to in Articles 15 to 20 shall be carried out by taking into account and providing protection for the individual rights or communal rights of indigenous peoples and cultural values that reflect local wisdom."
The legal representative for the Balik Sepaku Indigenous Community and AMAN, Yance Arizona, explained that the petitioners have suffered constitutional losses due to the implementation of spatial planning and land rights transfer in the IKN.
"The constitutional loss suffered by petitioners as a unity of indigenous law community is specific and actual due to the implementation of the five sectors regulated in Articles 15 to 20 of the IKN Law, namely spatial planning, land affairs, land rights transfer, environment, disaster mitigation, as well as defense and security," Yance said during the hearing of Case Number 299/PUU-XXIV/2026 on Tuesday (18/8/2026).
He explained that the Balik Sepaku indigenous community holds legal standing based on the enactment of East Kalimantan Provincial Regulation Number 1 of 2015 concerning Guidelines for the Recognition and Protection of Indigenous Law Communities, as well as Provincial Regulation Number 2 of 2017 on the Preservation and Protection of Paser Customs.
However, in the spatial planning of the Nusantara Capital City (IKN), the Balik Sepaku indigenous community was not involved by the IKN Authority.
A similar situation occurred in land affairs and land rights transfers, where the Balik Sepaku indigenous community was completely excluded and received no fair compensation.
The petitioners also highlighted the construction of several IKN infrastructures that caused the Balik Sepaku indigenous community to lose access to natural water sources and experience a decline in water quality.
"The construction of the Sepaku river intake and the Sepaku Semoi Dam for IKN purposes has resulted in reduced community access to natural water sources, deterioration of river water quality, drying up of fish ponds and residents' wells, as well as disruption to the ecological functions of the area which have long supported community livelihoods," Yance stated.
In their petition, the Balik Sepaku Indigenous Community and AMAN requested that the MK declare Article 21 of the IKN Law contrary to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia and conditionally unconstitutional insofar as it is not interpreted to mean:
Spatial planning, land affairs and land rights transfer, environmental management, disaster mitigation, as well as defense and security as referred to in Articles 15 to 20 shall be carried out only after obtaining the collective approval from indigenous peoples freely and without coercion based on true, complete, and understandable information, and providing protection for the individual rights or communal rights of indigenous peoples and cultural values that reflect local wisdom.
They also asked the MK to order the Head of the IKN Authority to monitor and review the IKN Authority Head Regulations related to spatial planning, land affairs and transfer of land rights, environmental management, disaster mitigation, as well as defense and security, and to make amendments ensuring the implementation of a mechanism for obtaining collective approval from indigenous peoples freely and without coercion based on accurate, complete, and understandable information, while providing protection for individual and communal indigenous rights and cultural values that reflect local wisdom.