The former Chairman of BPK was presented as an expert by the defendant Yaqut in court. He discussed how the hajj financial funds managed by BPKH are not state property.

Financial law expert Syakran Rudi emphasizes that the return of funds does not eliminate state losses in the 2023–2024 hajj corruption case.

State financial experts indicate that the hajj funds derived from congregational deposits, including those managed by BPKH, are a part of the state finance.

Menhaj Gus Irfan highlighted the Rp 184 trillion hajj fund managed by BPKH, emphasizing the need for optimal investment management while adhering to principles of prudence and sharia compliance.

The government has set the Haj fee (BPIH) at Rp 98.47 million, with pilgrims required to pay Rp 54.65 million. Despite the subsidy, both the DPR and the Haj Commission call for improved service quality and budget transparency.