• Login
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+

The Law Stammers Against the Powerful

21 November 2026, 07:54 WIB
Yusuf Warsim,
Sandro Gatra

Tim Redaksi

This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original

|

PALU a new ethical framework for top generals was established through Police Regulation Number 4 of 2026. The Indonesian National Police (Polri) is taking a progressive stance.

However, there is one question that makes this "new ethical regulation" feel awkward yet important.

The regulation was created because Polri needs to investigate former Chief of Police, General Listyo Sigit Prabowo, who is suspected of being involved in illegal wiretapping.

The issue is that the old rules regarding the composition of the Police Ethics Commission (KKEP) were at a standstill. How can a four-star general be investigated if the investigator must hold a higher rank than the one being investigated?

As a result, the rules were changed.

On the surface, this appears to be a technical solution. Beneath it lies a much larger question: why does law, which is so strong in judging subordinates, suddenly falter when it comes to judging those in the highest positions of power?

Can the law still be termed just if its creators themselves cannot be held accountable by the laws they enact?

When Law Only Applies Downwards

John Austin in The Province of Jurisprudence Determined (1832) described positive law as a command from a sovereign authority accompanied by threats of sanctions. Law binds because there is authority that establishes it.

Thomas Hobbes in Leviathan (1651) placed sovereignty as the guarantor of order. Without a strong authority, social life would descend into chaos.

Hans Kelsen in Pure Theory of Law (1960) offered a different perspective. The validity of law is not determined by the personal will of the sovereign, but by its position within a hierarchical system of norms.

These three thinkers differ significantly. Yet all indicate how closely law is intertwined with authority.

And it is here that the paradox emerges. When law is solely understood as an instrument for the ruler to regulate others, the lawmaker seems to exist beyond the reach of the law that they create.

This is reflected in the design of the old Police Regulation. Not because the highest officials are normatively immune from the law, but because there is no adequate mechanism for oversight, this immunity arises practically.

The law prohibits violations but does not provide a means to investigate the violators, thus harboring a flaw at the heart of its enforcement.

Is the issue rule by law or rule of law?

Here, we must remain sincere and clear in distinguishing between two often confused concepts.

As A.V. Dicey asserted in Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution (1885), the supremacy of law and equality of all individuals before the law are essential elements of the rule of law.

Not Rule by law, which positions law as a tool for exercising power. The ruler uses law to govern others.

But rather Rule of law, because it positions law as a limitation on power. Rulers themselves must submit to the law.

Our Constitution has already chosen the latter. Article 1 paragraph (3) of the 1945 Constitution states that Indonesia is a state of law.

Article 27 paragraph (1) guarantees the equality of citizens before the law and government. Article 28D paragraph (1) guarantees equal treatment before the law.

The consequences are clear: there must not be any area of power that is practically exempt from accountability.

The higher a person's position, the greater their authority, and correspondingly, the greater the need for independent and accountable oversight. Not the other way around.

Therefore, this new Police Regulation must not merely be an answer to investigate one former Chief of Police. It should be a momentum to improve the ethical enforcement system for all members of Polri, from the lowest to the highest ranks.

If not, we are simply replacing one hole with another. Equality is a promise of law enshrined in the 1945 Constitution.

Lon L. Fuller in The Morality of Law (1964) emphasizes a simple, yet often overlooked principle: there must be consistency between announced rules and their implementation.

If the code of ethics applies to all members of Polri, but the mechanisms for oversight are ineffective in reaching the highest officials, then there is a gap between normative promises and institutional reality. The law promises equality, but in practice, it does not.

John Rawls in A Theory of Justice (1971) reminds us that justice is not only determined by individual decisions but also by the justice of institutional structures.

Thus, the issue is not merely whether a general is proven to have committed a violation. First, there must be assurance of institutions capable of investigating anyone objectively and fairly.

Equality before the law does not always require an identical composition of investigators. However, that equality mandates standards of accountability, independence, and equal protection of rights.

It is essential to note that an investigation conducted by officers of a lower rank does not automatically guarantee independence.

Command relations, personal loyalties, conflicts of interest, and the shadow of power must still be anticipated. Without these safeguards, ethical hearings will merely become neatly organized formalities.

Key Lessons in Upholding the Rule of Law

Police Regulation Number 4 of 2026 can be understood as a response to urgent needs. However, the creation of norms must not be merely a solution for one case. It must be oriented towards the interests of sustainable institutional governance.

At least three reform agendas cannot be postponed.

First, establish ethical accountability mechanisms that apply universally to all ranks, including the highest officials. No position should be designed to be uninvestigable.

Second, ensure the independence of the KKEP and the KKEP Appeals. Regulate conflicts of interest, guarantee the freedom of investigators, and promote transparency in decision-making considerations. Without independence, regulatory changes will merely shift problems.

Third, ensure legal certainty and a fair process. This includes caution in applying changes to provisions regarding incidents that occurred before the new regulations came into effect.

Equality before the law must go hand in hand with due process of law. Equality does not mean that every suspect must be punished, but rather that everyone can be investigated fairly and only punished if their wrongdoing is proven.

When rulers submit to the law, that is the essence of a law-abiding state as the antithesis of a state of power.

This change in regulations presents important lessons about the nature of a rule-of-law state.

Law is indeed formed through authority. However, the authority to enact laws does not give its holders the right to exist outside the reach of the law.

In the perspective of constitutional ethics, the legitimacy of power cannot solely derive from the ability to create and enforce rules.

Legitimacy is also determined by the willingness of those in power to be accountable for their actions based on the same rules.

Therefore, the success of the new regulation must not only be measured by whether a former Chief of Police is sanctioned. It must be evaluated based on whether the system constructed can enforce ethics against anyone, without discrimination.

Our key lesson in upholding the rule of law is that the highest measure of a law-abiding state is not its ability to punish the weak.

Its measure is its capability to ensure that even the most powerful are not above the law.

And at this point, this regulation will be tested. Not on paper, but in how we apply it.



Comment wisely and responsibly. Comments are entirely the responsibility of the commentator as regulated in the ITE Law
Report
Thank You! We have received your report. We will remove comments that conflict with the Community Guidelines and the ITE Law.
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Close Ads

Copyright 2008 - 2026 PT. Kompas Cyber Media (Kompas Gramedia Digital Group). All Rights Reserved.

View