• Login
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+

Indonesia in the Mirror of Foreign Media

19 November 2026, 13:34 WIB
Nastiti S. Lestari,
Ferril Dennys

Tim Redaksi

This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original

“The Air Is Bad, the Economy Is Bad, the Vibe Is Bad.”

The title of a report by The New York Times, published on November 10, 2026, intertwines issues of air quality, the economy, and the mood of the Indonesian public in a single breath.

The focus is not solely on environmental conditions but also on disappointment with President Prabowo Subianto's administration.

Previously, on June 8, 2026, Reuters highlighted investor concerns regarding governance and economic policy direction amidst the weakening rupiah and external pressures.

Meanwhile, Malaysian daily The Star on November 9, 2026, reprinted a report from The Jakarta Post about limited infrastructure and shrinking green spaces making Jakarta vulnerable to flooding.

Though each outlet discusses different issues, they all raise questions about the government's ability to manage risks.

These reports certainly do not represent every viewpoint. Investors, residents affected by smoke, and people living in flood-prone areas each have distinct experiences.

However, this scrutiny should serve as an entry point to test the relationship between development direction, community protection, and citizens' trust in their government.

The question is not merely whether Indonesia is being portrayed negatively but, more crucially, what conditions are leading foreign media to write in such a manner?

Here lies the paradox of Indonesia: the economy is growing, yet the benefits may not be evenly distributed among citizens.

Aggregate figures may reflect progress, while parts of society continue to face economic uncertainty.

The crux is not whether growth is real but rather who benefits and who bears the burden.

Beyond Image Issues

In cultural criminology, as developed by Jeff Ferrell, Keith Hayward, and Jock Young, media does not merely reflect events but also shapes understandings of crime, victims, and social control.

From this perspective, reporting needs to be read with attention to whose experiences are highlighted, what threats are constructed, and whose responsibilities are emphasized.

Thus, foreign reporting should neither be accepted as a final judgment nor dismissed as an attack.

Accepting or rejecting it outright only distances us from the more important task of examining the evidence.

When floods are reported, for instance, do explanations stop at heavy rainfall, or do they extend to issues of spatial planning and the protection of water catchment areas?

When economic growth is reported, does the focus only center on rising figures, or does it also consider households' ability to meet daily needs?

Who is given a chance to explain, and whose experiences remain invisible?

These questions shift the discussion from national pride to the basis of reporting and accountability.

Foreign scrutiny is valuable not because external judgments are always correct, but because it can open space to examine matters long taken for granted.

Understanding Citizen Loss

Foreign media focus leads us to consider the losses experienced by citizens. Zemiology studies social harm without limiting it to acts categorized as criminal offenses.

One of its cornerstones is Beyond Criminology: Taking Harm Seriously (2004), edited by Paddy Hillyard and colleagues.

The premise is simple: just because something is not legally prohibited does not mean it does not cause harm. Conversely, the existence of rules does not automatically ensure societal protection.

Social harm studies urge us to examine how decisions, institutional practices, and social structures impact human life.

From this perspective, environmental and economic issues must not merely be seen as reputational disturbances.

Analysis should explore who suffers from health issues, loss of income, or recurrent threats; how those harms occur; and which aspects might actually be preventable.

This does not imply that every disappointing policy is a crime. A decline in investor confidence does not automatically prove harm to the entire population.

Causal relationships must be tested, not assumed. Without clear boundaries, the term social harm can lose its precision.

Examining Responsibility

Foreign reporting should be cross-referenced with domestic data, citizen experiences, and government explanations. Errors must be corrected with evidence, while substantiated critiques need to be addressed through action.

A report by The Star, for instance, also noted the Jakarta Provincial Government’s efforts to expedite river normalization and prepare emergency facilities.

Such efforts deserve acknowledgment, but the existence of programs does not automatically indicate success.

The measure is whether risks are reduced, vulnerable groups are protected, and recurring losses can be prevented.

Citizen difficulties should not only gain importance after being reported by international media.

Foreign scrutiny should strengthen demands for solutions, not become a prerequisite for their voices to be heard.

“Indonesia in the mirror of foreign media” is not merely a story about external perceptions of this nation.

It opens room to examine what is displayed, what is overlooked, and which issues remain unaddressed.

Chairil Anwar may be “reluctant to share” with the mirror in his love poem.

A nation cannot choose only the pleasant reflections. The suffering of its citizens should not be obscured merely because it disturbs its image.



Comment wisely and responsibly. Comments are entirely the responsibility of the commentator as regulated in the ITE Law
Report
Thank You! We have received your report. We will remove comments that conflict with the Community Guidelines and the ITE Law.
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Read without ads. Subscribe KOMPAS.com+
Close Ads

Copyright 2008 - 2026 PT. Kompas Cyber Media (Kompas Gramedia Digital Group). All Rights Reserved.

View