Betrayal in the Whirlwind of Power
-
News
-
2 minutes ago
Writer
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - Article 136 paragraph (1) of the Indonesian Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP), which states, “Investigators may conduct wiretapping for investigative purposes,” is currently being challenged before the Constitutional Court.
In the hearing of case number 416/PUU-XXIV/2026 led by Chief Justice Suhartoyo, along with Justices Daniel Yusmic P. Foekh and M. Guntur Hamzah on Wednesday (18/11/2026), the petitioners argued that this provision grants wiretapping authority without conditions.
“The norm a quo gives investigators the authority to wiretap without any conditions regarding the type of crime, evidence threshold, court permission, or duration,” stated the petition presented to the Constitutional Court on Wednesday.
The petitioners argue that Article 1 number 36 of the KUHAP defines wiretapping as the activity of secretly obtaining personal information, including listening, recording, and noting electronic information transmissions via both wired and wireless networks.
In this case, phone calls to the petitioners fall squarely within this definition.
Wiretapping one number always captures two parties: the targeted number's owner and anyone who speaks with them.
Therefore, petitioners can be inadvertently wiretapped without ever being suspects, simply by calling or receiving calls from the person whose number is being tapped.
The petitioners cannot know about this situation because the wiretapping is done secretly and the KUHAP does not require any notification to anyone.
“The harm is actual and/or at least potentially present. Since the enactment of the norm a quo on January 2, 2026, without any transitional provisions delaying its implementation, the dangers of unchecked wiretapping authority have clearly resulted in harm,” the petitioners asserted.
On the basis of these arguments, the petitioners, namely Pardamean Sihombing, Matthew Febrian Otniel Lambok Hutasoit, Eprina Manurung, and Christian Adrianus Sihite, request the Constitutional Court to amend Article 136 paragraph 1 of the KUHAP.
They ask the Court to modify the rule so that wiretapping can only be carried out with a court’s approval within a maximum of 24 hours. If permission is not granted, the wiretapping must be halted and the results cannot be used as evidence.