The Risks of Becoming Gibran's Successor as Vice President
-
News
-
Just now
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
BUDGET EFFICIENCY in government is a necessity. There is no reason for the state to tolerate waste, unproductive bureaucratic spending, excessive business trips, or programs that fail to provide tangible benefits to society.
Government must be managed in a frugal, effective, transparent, and accountable manner.
However, one thing must not be forgotten: efficiency is not the ultimate goal of governance.
The end goal is effectiveness, which ensures that the state can fulfill its obligations and provide the best services to the people.
This is where the issue of central government budget efficiency policies needs to be critically examined. The spirit of saving public funds should not diminish the government's ability to perform its basic functions.
Moreover, when budget cuts also target transfers to regions (TKD), which are the primary funding sources for most local governments, the stakes are even higher.
Efficiency that sacrifices effectiveness is not smart savings. It has the potential to create waste in another form: deteriorating public services, delayed development, and an increasing social burden for the community.
The fundamental issue is not merely how much of the budget is cut, but how these cuts are implemented and who bears the consequences.
When the central government significantly reduces transfers to regions while various national priority programs still require substantial budget support, it raises questions about the fiscal policy direction of the government.
Is this really a fiscal reform aimed at improving the quality of government spending, or does it signify a path toward rekindled central control over resources and governance?
We must remember that regional autonomy is not a favor from the central government. It is a constitutional mandate.
Article 18 Paragraph (5) of the 1945 Constitution explicitly states that regional governments exercise the broadest autonomy, except for matters determined by law as the domain of the central government.
This means that decentralization is a constitutional choice in building Indonesia's governance framework, not merely an administrative policy that can be changed at the whim of those in power.
Consequently, the central government should not implement efficiency measures by excessively reclaiming authority, fiscal resources, and decision-making space from the regions.
Moreover, Article 18A Paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution mandates that financial relations, public services, and the utilization of resources between the central and regional governments must be regulated and executed fairly and harmoniously according to law.
The terms fair and harmonious carry significant meaning. The center must not dominate the majority of fiscal resources while regions bear an increasing responsibility for public services without adequate funding support.
Regions should not merely be assigned responsibilities while their capabilities are stripped away.
We need to understand the fiscal structure of regional governments in Indonesia. Of 546 autonomous regions, most still have limited original income (PAD) capacity. Their dependency on transfers from the central government remains very high.
In such circumstances, cutting TKD is not merely a technical budget issue. The impact directly affects the ability of regional governments to pay employee obligations, provide education and healthcare, repair roads, supply clean water, and build basic infrastructure.
The symptoms are already apparent. Several regions are struggling to pay salaries for Government Employees Under Work Agreements (PPPK).
The structural official's TPP has been cut. Infrastructure projects have to be postponed, and even public service programs are threatened with reductions.
Ironically, regional governments are still held accountable for governance issues that fall under their authority as stipulated in Law Number 23 of 2014 on Regional Government.
How can regions be asked to improve service quality, accelerate development, and prosper their citizens if their fiscal capabilities are continuously narrowed?
Regional governments should not just be reduced to administrative implementers without adequate fiscal capacity. Regional autonomy must not be allowed to exist formally while being substantively dead.
We must also avoid priority discrepancies. National programs are indeed important and should be supported. However, central government programs should not develop at the expense of regional government programs that directly address community needs.
The state must not only appear present through major programs at the central level but must also be there when the people need decent roads, functioning health clinics, adequate schools, and prompt administrative services.
There is a belief that reclaiming authority and budgets to the center can minimize corruption in regions. This view oversimplifies the issue.
Experience in governance shows that corruption is not solely a result of decentralization. During highly centralized power, corruption practices also thrived at the center.
Conversely, after powers and resources are decentralized, corruption can potentially spread to the regions, even to the village level.
In other words, centralization does not automatically clean up corruption, just as decentralization does not automatically produce clean governance.
Corruption thrives when power is unchecked, authority is not matched with accountability, and governance control systems do not function properly.
The real problem lies in the weak governance structure, both at the center and in the regions.
In the regions, mechanisms for overseeing regional heads face serious challenges. The Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) which is supposed to carry out oversight and checks and balances is often not sufficiently independent due to political relationships and dependence on regional heads.
Local inspectorates also face structural conflicts of interest because they operate within the power sphere of the regional heads they oversee.
In such situations, who is truly overseeing governors, regents, and mayors?
Therefore, the solution to combat corruption is not to pull all authority back to Jakarta. What is needed is to reform the oversight system, strengthen bureaucratic integrity, ensure budget transparency, enforce consistent legal processes, and enhance community control.
Decentralization must be accompanied by strong capacity and oversight. Without this, corruption simply changes location rather than disappearing.
In the current fiscal situation, the Ministry of Home Affairs should play a strategic role as a facilitator for regional governance while also bridging the interests of the center and the regions.
However, we must also be realistic. The Ministry of Home Affairs is part of the central government and a subordinate to the President. In practice, this ministry must align with presidential policy directives.
Therefore, it is not enough for the defense of regional interests to rest solely with the Ministry of Home Affairs.
Other institutions with a constitutional mandate to advocate for regional interests are needed. One of these is the Regional Representative Council (DPD) of the Republic of Indonesia.
From the beginning, the DPD was designed to represent regions within Indonesia's constitutional framework. Four senators from each province are directly elected by the people, not chosen through political party nominations.
This position should make the DPD a guardian of regional interests, including advocating for fiscal justice and the sustainability of regional autonomy. The DPD must act as the the guardian of regional autonomy.
Unfortunately, so far, the DPD's role has not been sufficiently strong. Limited constitutional authority and weak political bargaining power mean that regional voices are often not sufficiently influential in national decision-making processes.
Therefore, the DPD's initiative through the Senator Greeting program should be appreciated and developed. Senators should not spend too much time in Jakarta.
They should often be in the regions, listening to community issues, dialoguing with regional heads, and conveying concrete aspirations to the center.
Senators should not be known more as bureaucrats stationed in Senayan than as regional representatives advocating for the interests of the populace in their provinces.
The DPD must dare to speak out when central policies are unjust to the regions. They also need to actively advocate for evaluating decentralization designs, including addressing regions unable to exercise their governance functions or the need to establish new regions that are truly viable.
However, fighting for regional interests cannot rely solely on the DPD. Regional heads and civil society must also play a role.
Regional heads should not merely be recipients of central decisions. They must boldly voice objections when national fiscal policies threaten the sustainability of public services in their areas.
Lobbying the central government should be systematic, transparent, and data-driven. If formal communication does not yield results, regional heads must not shy away from explaining the challenges they face to the public.
The voice of regional heads should not be perceived as defiance against the central government. Instead, it is part of their political responsibility to the community that elected and entrusted them with leadership.
Of course, such criticism must be accompanied by measured arguments, not merely complaints about budget cuts.
Regional heads must be able to show how significantly cutting TKD impacts services in education, health, infrastructure, PPPK payments, and regional priority programs.
Universities and civil society should also be involved. Local campuses have the capability to conduct research, policy analysis, and fiscal impact assessments. The findings from these studies need to be published as feedback for the central government.
Thus, the struggle to uphold regional autonomy should not turn into mere tug-of-war between elite interests at the center and the regions. What must be fought for is the people's right to receive fair and quality public services.
Ultimately, the issue of budget efficiency must be placed within a larger framework, namely how to build healthy, fair, and mutually reinforcing central-regional relations.
The central government indeed has the authority to set national priorities. However, this authority must not reduce regions to mere administrative subordinates waiting for commands and budget allocations from Jakarta.
A comprehensive evaluation of the central-regional fiscal relationship design is needed.
First, cuts to TKD should be based on evaluations of regional performance and real needs, not applied uniformly without considering the fiscal capacity and service burdens of each region.
Second, the government must guarantee adequate funding for governance matters that have been delegated to regions. Responsibilities should not be decentralized while the funding sources are pulled back to the center.
Third, national priority programs should be aligned with regional development planning. The center's programs must not consume regional fiscal space without considering the obligations of local governments as mandated by law.
Fourth, oversight improvements must run parallel with strengthening autonomy. Independent oversight, functional DPRD, professional inspectorates, and community participation are prerequisites for ensuring that decentralization does not become a breeding ground for corruption.
The President needs to ensure that efficiency policies do not deviate from constitutional mandates. Saving budgets is a government obligation, but maintaining the sustainability of regional autonomy is also a constitutional responsibility.
Let us not regress to a centralist governance pattern left behind in the name of efficiency that has proven incapable of addressing the diversity and complexity of Indonesia.
Indonesia is not just Jakarta. The nation’s progress should not only be measured by the central government's success in executing national programs.
It must also be assessed by the ability of 546 autonomous regions to deliver services, develop their territories, and enhance the welfare of their citizens.
Efficiency may cut waste, but it must not cut justice. Effectiveness must remain the measure, and regional autonomy must continue to be a constitutional commitment.
Because if regions are weakened in the name of savings, what is truly being saved is not the state budget, but the future of public services and local democracy.