DPR Receives Four Presidential Letters, Including Bills on Broadcasting and the Chamber of Commerce
-
News
-
Just now
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
"In this video, there is no defense, and I apologize."
THAT STATEMENT was made by Raffi Ahmad on Monday (16/11/2026). For a presidential special envoy, such a candid apology is rarely heard.
However, the short video also contained another announcement: a commitment of IDR 15 billion for those affected by disasters in Pidie Jaya and Gayo Lues, from himself along with Ariel, Desta, and Gading Marten. This is where the trouble began.
Both things were announced almost in one breath—an apology regarding state contracts and a donation for disaster victims.
The two are not the same, and the public has the right to hold them accountable in different ways.
The IDR 14.69 billion contract identified by Indonesia Corruption Watch must be answered with an audit whose results are made public.
The donation can simply be accounted for with a distribution report. And until the audit is published, any new procurement of influencer services should be postponed.
Indonesia Corruption Watch released its findings on November 9, 2026, after tracing procurement data on the INAPROC portal of the Government Procurement Policy Agency.
The result showed eight packages for PT Rans Animasi Indonesia, totaling IDR 14,696,955,002.
Five packages came from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology in 2024, worth IDR 3.9 billion.
The other three packages came from the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries in 2025 and 2026, totaling IDR 10,796,955,000.
These eight packages are often read as one issue.
However, they are not. Raffi was appointed as the Presidential Special Envoy on October 22, 2024, and according to his explanation in the video, the collaboration in 2024 took place before he held that position.
Thus, the questions about the first five packages stop at what is usually asked about any government spending.
Is the work necessary, is the price reasonable, and why do the specifications point to specific accounts, as highlighted by Indonesia Corruption Watch?
The packages from the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries are a different matter.
They were signed while Raffi was already in office, prompting unavoidable additional questions: who recorded and prevented conflicts of interest in this?
Presidential Regulation Number 16 of 2018, in Article 7, requires those involved in procurement to avoid and prevent conflicts of interest, and this obligation does not end simply by stating that the work has been completed.
The context is also detrimental. On January 22, 2025, Presidential Instruction Number 1 of 2025 was issued, targeting efficiency in spending of IDR 306,695,177,420,000 while ordering limitations on promotional expenditure.
However, Indonesia Corruption Watch's records indicate that the ministry actually signed two packages worth IDR 7.2 billion throughout 2025 and added another package worth IDR 3.6 billion in 2026.
The company likely has its calculations. In a disclosure to the Indonesia Stock Exchange on November 10, 2026, PT Rans Entertainment Indonesia Tbk stated that four campaigns generated over 150 outputs and 52.6 million impressions.
Their costs, according to the company, are not just posting fees: they include content production, travel to locations such as Karawang, Rote Ndao, and Natuna, logistics, and attendance at events.
This claim can be tested with simple calculations. Dividing the total contract of IDR 14,696,955,002 by 150 outputs gives IDR 97,979,700 per output.
If divided by 52.6 million impressions, that yields IDR 279 per impression.
Since the denominator uses the lowest number from the company’s claims, this result represents the highest possible unit cost.
This does not prove that the price is too high; it simply shows that questions about price justification are grounded in calculations, and only an audit can resolve them fully.
On the other hand, the needs of the people in Pidie Jaya and Gayo Lues are real.
The National Disaster Mitigation Agency recorded that as of November 11, 2026, floods affected 32,272 people in Pidie Jaya, while 390 people were impacted in Gayo Lues.
Combined, that’s 32,662 people. If IDR 15 billion is equally divided among them, each person would receive about IDR 459,249.
Of course, no aid distribution operates on such an even basis; this calculation merely illustrates how a large figure in the news headline diminishes in contrast to the number of people needing assistance.
There is one aspect that prevents this donation from being regarded as entirely separate from the contract.
Raffi himself mentioned that the source is his personal funds, plus all compensation received by Ariel, Desta, and Gading from their collaboration with the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries.
Part of the IDR 15 billion, in other words, once passed through as payment from the currently disputed contract.
This does not render his help illegitimate, as assistance for flood-affected residents cannot wait for controversy to be resolved.
However, it underscores that what can be separated from this case is solely how to account for the funds, not the origin of the money.
French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu has a concept for such occurrences known as symbolic capital, which he explained in Le Sens Pratique in 1980.
This means: Wealth or status transforms into honor when the public stops questioning its source and begins to remember who gave it.
A selfless donation, or one that appears selfless, diverts attention from the process of acquiring resources to the magnitude of assistance and how quickly it arrives.
The reputation formed from this then works far beyond the event of the donation itself.
No one needs to be accused of intending this way, as the mechanism operates independently.
The problem is, the state must not get embroiled in it. For the people of Pidie Jaya, IDR 15 billion is aid.
For taxpayers, IDR 14.69 billion is spending that must be documented item by item.
These two statements can both be true simultaneously, and the error arises when they are merged into a single impression, as if the donation has resolved the accounting issue.
The Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries, through its public relations statement, reminds that delivering programs to the public is indeed the ministry's duty, and the channels are not limited to influencers; there are print media, television, and digital channels.
This reminder has merit, as ministries that cease communication also fail in their responsibilities.
However, the initial issue is not the existence of public communication.
The issue is the price, specifications, and the timing of when the packages were signed.
Thus, the criteria can be established now, and they are quite simple. Allow thirty days from the release of that apology video.
By December 16, 2026, the ministry's inspectorate, along with the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency, should have issued a summary of the examination of those eight packages—what constitutes a fair price according to comparisons, how the specifications were developed, and how conflicts of interest in the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries' package have been managed.
Concurrently, the donation distributors should release their own report detailing how much of the IDR 15 billion has arrived, to how many citizens, and in which villages.
The figure of 32,662 individuals affected from the National Disaster Mitigation Agency is available as a comparison.
Until that summary is released, any new procurement for influencer services in ministries under investigation should be postponed.
This is not a prohibition against any company participating, as such a ban would violate the principles of competition and fairness.
What is being postponed is the category until the state completes its explanation regarding the same category this year.
If on December 16 those two reports are published, Raffi Ahmad's apology will be remembered as a positive beginning.
If not, all that remains is a donation that helps flood victims, alongside unresolved questions about public funds.