PKH Task Force: PT RAPP Repeatedly Causes Land and Forest Fires
-
News
-
13 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - The legal team of PT Mercy Toga Kirana, the plaintiff regarding the high school equivalency certificate owned by Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, revealed their reasons for walking out and requesting to withdraw their lawsuit from the Jakarta Administrative Court (PTUN) on Wednesday (29/10/2026).
Constitutional Law Professor Denny Indrayana, a member of the legal team, stated that the case number 255/G/2026/PTUN.JKT was filed at the Jakarta PTUN in July 2025, long before the Constitutional Court (MK) ruled on a similar case in October 2026.
“We filed the lawsuit earlier at the Jakarta PTUN. That is one of the reasons we consider withdrawing it from the court,” said Denny, as quoted from a Kompas TV broadcast on Friday (30/10/2026).
The first reason is the issuance of MK's decision number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, which found no evidence that Gibran holds a high school diploma or its equivalent.
“When the MK ruling declared there is no proof of completing high school or equivalent education, the very essence of this certificate has been lost,” Denny stated.
“Therefore, with the MK ruling, it is clear that the spirit of this certificate is gone; there is no proof of completing high school. Moreover, we remember that MK's ruling is final and binding,” he added.
Following the MK ruling, PT Mercy Toga Kirana's legal team began to contemplate withdrawing their lawsuit from the Jakarta PTUN.
The second reason is that the legal team does not want the PTUN trial process to inadvertently delegitimize the MK ruling.
“We must ensure that the MK ruling, as one of the highest courts, is not downgraded or rendered illegitimate through the PTUN process,” he remarked.
According to the administrative law procedures, a lawsuit that has passed the defendant's reply stage can only be withdrawn with the defendant’s consent.
In this context, the PTUN Jakarta hearing on Thursday (29/10/2026) was already in the stage of the plaintiff's electronic reply and additional conventional evidence from both the plaintiff and defendant.
“But if the defendant has already responded, then the withdrawal must have the defendant's consent. We can submit our letter first. Who knows, they might provide that evidence. So you never know, the defendant might want to present the documents,” he explained.
Additionally, he believes that the trial process in the PTUN is not proceeding properly because the defendant has not provided the documents that formed the basis for issuing the certificate.
Denny mentioned that the legal team had previously requested the documents verbally several times.
The presiding judge was also reported to have requested the defendant to present the evidence that supported the issuance of the certificate.