Assessing the Urgency of the AI Law: What Should be Regulated?
-
News
-
12 minutes ago
This article was translated by AI. Read the original article on Kompas.com. See Original
JAKARTA, KOMPAS.com - The 2029 elections still have time for preparation. However, several fundamental decisions regarding the rules of this democratic event need to be resolved through discussions on the revision of the Election Law (UU Pemilu) in the DPR and the government.
The draft Election Law contains various strategic issues, ranging from the electoral system, electoral districts, parliamentary thresholds, nominations, to the institutional design of election organizers.
Changes to these provisions not only dictate the rules of political competition but also impact the technical preparations that election organizers must undertake.
Yet, discussions on the Election Bill have been hindered by various dynamics.
One key issue is the formation of a selection committee (pansel) for commissioners of the General Election Commission (KPU) and the Election Supervisory Body (Bawaslu).
Commission II of the DPR has opted to wait for the passage of the new Election Law before forming the KPU-Bawaslu selection committee.
Neni Nur Hayati, Director of the Democracy and Electoral Empowerment Partnership (DEEP) Indonesia, believes that discussions on the Election Law could be prolonged because any changes can affect the distribution of political representation, the design of competition, and the quality of democracy.
On the other hand, the lack of certainty regarding the timing of the legislation raises concerns about readiness for implementation.
KPU and Bawaslu will need time to adjust implementing regulations, organizational structures, budgets, information systems, and operational procedures if there are fundamental changes to the law.
So, how realistic is it for the new Election Law to be completed on time? What impacts should be anticipated if discussions drag on, and what should the DPR and government prioritize to ensure the preparation for the 2029 elections is not disrupted?
Amidst criticism regarding delays in forming the selection committee, Chairman of Commission II of the DPR, Rifqinizamy Karsayuda, has suggested that the government waits for the passage of the new Election Law.
He argues that this approach is the safest scenario since the new regulations will serve as guidelines for KPU and Bawaslu in conducting the upcoming elections in 2029.
"The selection material will refer to the provisions of the new election law, which will be a reference for the election organizers at both KPU and Bawaslu in conducting the 2029 elections," Rifqinizamy told reporters on Tuesday (27/10/2026).
The Nasdem Party politician stated that the government could still form the selection committee based on Law No. 7 of 2017 on Elections.
However, he recommended that the nomination of candidates for KPU and Bawaslu members be submitted to the DPR after the new regulations are enacted.
According to Rifqinizamy, changes to the law could potentially affect the composition of members of both bodies.
Moreover, the new regulations may alter the duration of stages and the recruitment mechanisms, making it necessary to adjust the selection process to comply with the applicable provisions.
"The second scenario, or the safest scenario, is the formation of the selection committee after the new law is enacted," he said.
He also argued that the debate about the deadline for forming the committee should consider the potential changes in the new Election Law.
"The debate over timing has become irrelevant because we do not yet know how long the phases will be in the new law, including the mandatory deadlines for the selection process to be conducted by the committee and the DPR under the new election law," Rifqinizamy explained.
Nevertheless, he assured that Commission II of the DPR is ready to perform the eligibility and suitability tests for the candidates for KPU and Bawaslu members in accordance with legal provisions.
Meanwhile, the government has yet to make a final decision regarding the formation of the selection committee.
Home Affairs Minister Tito Karnavian stated that the government is still waiting for perspectives from political parties in the DPR, particularly regarding the composition of the number of committee members.
In fact, the formation of the KPU committee, according to Law No. 7 of 2017, should have been completed no later than October 12, 2026.
"As I understand it, based on the existing law, the process for the selection committee can still be carried out. But we are also waiting for opinions from other parties regarding this, especially the number of members," Tito said at the Ministry of Home Affairs in Central Jakarta on Wednesday (28/10/2026).
Tito also responded to the proposal for issuing a Government Regulation in Lieu of Law (Perppu) to address the delays in forming the committee.